INTERVIEW'The Tribunal will meet international standards'
In an exclusive interview with bdnews24.com, law minister Shafique Ahmed explains to David Bergman why he thinks the war crimes trials will meet international standards and why he discounts criticisms from international lawyers.
bdnews24.com News Service
bdnews24.com
Published :
12 Aug 2010, 03:37 AM
Updated :
24 Apr 2022, 05:35 PM
David Bergman
bdnews24.com Editor for Special Reports
Dhaka, Aug 12 (bdnews24.com) – In Bangladesh, the trials of those accused of war crimes during the 1971 War of Independence has been long awaited - and so it should come as no surprise that the first hearings of the newly established International Crimes Tribunal were heralded with great enthusiasm.
There is no doubt that the government has the country's support in holding these trials; probably, the metaphorical fingers of just one hand are needed to count the number of ordinary people in the country opposed to them.
Sitting in his office, Shafique Ahmed, the law minister, the person within the government responsible for setting the trial process in motion, explained to bdnews24.com why he thought it was so important, nearly 39 years after the end of the war, for these trials to go ahead.
"First it is to put an end to the culture of impunity," he said. "Secondly, the victims must get justice. This is an expectation of the civilized world. Thirdly, we want to heal the wounds that the nation has been suffering these 39 years.
"And finally, it is to put an end to the shameful legacy of the past, so that in the future these kinds of crimes are not repeated in the civilized world."
These are ambitious objectives for any trial process to achieve, but Ahmed asserts that the Tribunal will be of the highest standard. "The government has always said that these trials will meet international standards, and they will," he said.
"The trials," he goes on, "will not violate human rights and any number of observers can attend and due process of law will be truly observed.
"The Tribunal is truly independent and will also ensure fair justice and the accused will be given full opportunity to defend themselves with any number of lawyers of their own choice.
"And they will also be allowed to cross examine witnesses and challenge any document that can be used against them. And if convicted they can go to the appellate division. I can assure you due process will be maintained".
At this early stage, it is not possible to judge what will be the standard of these trials. They will certainly differ from most other criminal trials in Bangladesh – in that the Evidence Act 1872, and the Code of Criminal Procedure 1898 will not apply to them, and because the defendants' normal constitutional protections will not apply.
Although most Bangladesh supporters of the process seem to feel that, despite the removal of these safeguards, the Tribunal will match appropriate standards, independent observers outside the country have raised some significant concerns about the trials with the government.
In early 2009, the minister received detailed advice from the UN Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights on amendments to ensure that the 1973 International Crimes (Tribunal) Act met international standards.
Subsequently, he received a legal opinion written in December 2009 by the International Bar Association, setting out 17 amendments that should be made to the Act.
Most recently, a Hong Kong-based academic has raised further questions about the legislation and the tribunal process.
The minister, however, is dismissive.
"Have you read what the IBA report says in its introduction?" he asks, referring to a passage of the IBA document that states that the Act provides a system that is 'broadly compatible with current international standards'.
"When someone says that you are good man," the minister goes on, "that person can't then go onto say you are a bad one."
In relation to the UN advice, he said, "We made one or two changes to the Act based on those comments. The Act no longer allows military judges to be members of the tribunal. We also added in a sentence in the Act, saying that the Tribunal would be independent in the exercise of its judicial functions and shall ensure fair trial. It was not necessary to make other changes."
He points, for example, to the new section that makes it obligatory for the Tribunal to ensure a "fair trial."
"This commitment allows anything to be included in it. Sometimes in law it is better to say less than say more. The Tribunal can include many things in the commitment to a fair trial."
So, for example, the minister does not think that the Act or the Rules of Procedure need to mention the level of proof necessary to convict a person.
"You cannot convict a man unless you can prove the case 'beyond reasonable doubt'. This is normal criminal jurisprudence that the court will follow. It does not need to be set out in the Act."
He also does not think the offence of "Crime against Humanity" should have been amended to clarify that the crimes of murder, rape etc must be committed as part of a "widespread or systematic attack" about which that person was aware – the standard definition in international law.
"Whatever the law is in other countries it must be looked into by the Tribunal," he says.
"It is not possible to mention everything in the Act," he continues. "Laws from around the world will be considered. We cannot rely on our standards only - we must see what happened in similar situations in other courts and what they have done, and take those decisions into account"
However, the minister must know that it was the government's failure to make detailed amendments that lay behind the United Nations and other countries' decision not to offer any substantive support to the tribunals.
About this, again, Shafique Ahmed does not appear concerned. "This is not an international tribunal, it is a domestic tribunal. The international community has said to us that due process must be followed. And we say to them that, yes 100% due process will be followed."
With five accused now in jail, the Tribunal is facing some immediate issues about defendant's rights.
The tribunal's rules of procedure are silent on whether the defendant's lawyers will be allowed to be present during any police questioning – not something allowed in Bangladesh, but a standard right in all the international tribunals organised.
In a surprising response, the law minister told bdnews24.com that he did not think that the suspects would be questioned when they were in custody. "We have materials, collected from around the world. We have the witnesses. I don't think we will need to question them," he said.
When asked about the impact of the first constitutional amendment – as enshrined in articles 47(3)and 47A of the Constitution – which seem to remove all constitutional protections from the accused, and prevent them from seeking a remedy from the High Court, the minister suggested that this should not be a great concern. "The Tribunal itself has the power to provide constitutional rights if it wants to," he said.
Significantly, he assumes that the amendment will be challenged. "The defendants can go to High Court if they have a proper challenge and ask whether the amendment applies to a particular issue or not. The High Court can look at whether the tribunal can protect itself from scrutiny through these amendments."
Though the minister is clearly basking in the popular response to the trials, on one point he does seem to differ from some of his supporters.
"I don't think that those people who raise questions about international standards are necessarily motivated," he said.
And in his final flourish the minister says, "There cannot be any flaws, cannot be any violation in the due process and in the human rights of the defendents. That is a guarantee. That is the assurance I will give. In short, I can assure you that the trial will meet international standards."
However, only time will tell whether the Tribunal will in fact live up to the minister's confidence. With limited law constraining the conduct of the Tribunal, much rests on the Tribunal members themselves constructing a proper and fair process. And whether they do so, we will just have to simply wait and see.
david.bergman@bdnews24.com
bdnews24.com/db/am/bd/db/0925h