ICT will not remove Justice Nizamul Huq
The war crimes tribunal has said the laws do not provide the judges to remove co-judge Justice Nizamul Huq as petitioned by the Jamaat-e-Islami's leader Delwar Hossain Sayedee. Updates 2
bdnews24.com News Service
bdnews24.com
Published :
14 Nov 2011, 07:09 AM
Updated :
10 Aug 2022, 05:48 PM
Tanim Ahmed
Dhaka, Nov 14 (bdnews24.com) —The war crimes tribunal has said the laws do not provide the judges to remove co-judge Justice Nizamul Huq as petitioned by the Jamaat-e-Islami's leader Delwar Hossain Sayedee.
Accused of crimes against humanity and indicted on 20 counts of murder, rape, loot and genocide, Jamaat executive council member appealed on Oct 27 that the tribunal chief removes himself from the proceedings.
The hearing was fixed on Nov 13 when the remaining two judges, AKM Zaheer Ahmed and ATM Fazle Kabir, heard the defence and prosecution.
On Monday, the tribunal ruled that the International Crimes Tribunal Act, which governs the tribunal gave equal power to the three judges and designated one as the chairman.
Reading out the order, Fazle Kabir noted that Sayedee's counsel Abdur Razzaq had cited a number of precedents where a judge had been removed. However, Fazle Kabir said that having perused the legal provisions of those courts, including the special court of Sierra Leone, the tribunal found that those judges were empowered by special laws that allowed them to make such a ruling against a fellow judge.
The judge observed that the defence had argued for the Huq's recusal showing that the tribunal chairman had been part of a people's enquiry commission where he collected evidence against Sayedee, besides a few other Jamaat leaders who are also currently charged with war crimes. In doing so, the defence contended, thejudge has already formed an opinion against Sayedee and may harbour a certain perception that would compromise his neutrality.
Judge Fazle Kabir mentioned that Razzaq had then said Justice Huq had disqualified himself since his neutrality had been reasonably constrained.
He also noted that prosecutors Syed Haider Ali and Mohammad Ali had argued that the application was not maintainable since the legal provisions did not provide for the tribunal to make any such ruling.
Fazle Kabir stated in his ruling that Haider had pointed out in his submission on Sunday that the people's enquiry commission, involvement in which had rendered Huq unfit as a judge according to the defence, only recommended that that the crimes of 1971 be tried.
According to Haider Ali, Huq was only acting in the interest of justice at that time, which he is allowed to do even as a sitting judge.
Furthermore, Haider had also said that other than the fact that Huq's name appears as one of the enquiry commission's members, there is no evidence that he had collected evidence and testimonies actively. Mere inclusion of his name, taken together with the commission's recommendation, is not enough to disqualify the judge.
Not only did the commission have no legal coverage, its report was also not accepted by the government and the proceedings were not part of any court of law in Bangladesh, the judge further noted.
Fazle Kabir then said that the judges deemed it a most pertinent question whether the tribunal had any authority to dispose of a recusal hearing. "But the tribunal as bound by the 1973 Act cannot pass such an order."
The tribunal also ruled regarding a newspaper report published on Nov 10 in Jamaat mouthpiece daily Sangram. The report mentions an email sent by three lawyers, claiming to be Sayedee's lawyers, to Nizamul Huq requesting him to recuse himself for being unfit to hold the trial.
AKM Zaheer Ahmed, reading out that ruling, noted that the registrar had received an email on Nov 9 from Steven Kay QC, Toby Cadman and John Cammegh, addressed to the tribunal chief. The three lawyers of 9 Bedford Row, which is said to be a leading law firm in England, urged Huq to step aside in the interest of justice.
Zaheer Ahmed noted that as a footnote to the email, it mentioned that the letter was confidential and should anyone receive it in error, it should be deleted immediately and the IT department of the British law firm should be notified. However, the email was obviously forwarded to Bangladeshi media.
The judge then concluded that this letter was not at all confidential but only meant to create further embarrassment for the tribunal chief Huq.
At the beginning of the proceedings, the judges also wanted to confirm whether Sayedee had engaged foreign lawyers, to which he said that they had been hired through his local lawyers. The judge noted that the documents did not show any proof that Sayedee had engaged the services of such lawyers, thus they could only serve in an unofficial capacity.
However, Zaheer Ahmed observed that such behaviour by the three British counsels violated the rules and customs of the bar, both in England as well as in Bangladesh.
The judge then went on to state the three counsels had been making public statements and making appearances on TV with the intention of discrediting the proceedings of justice at the International Crimes Tribunal.
He then read out a long list of television interviews, published articles and statements that the three had issued or written at different times. These included interviews with Al Jazeera and articles criticising the tribunal.
"They can say that they have right to express their opinion. Yes they do, but only in an educational and academic context," said the judge.
Zaheer directed the tribunal registrar to notify the British authorities of such activities, and also asked the law secretary to make sure that appropriate steps are taken in this regard
At the hearing on Sunday, Huq's chair was moved to one side and remained empty.
Arguing for the recusal of International Crimes Tribunal chairman, the defence had said on Sunday it would be tantamount to obstructing the course of justice if he does not step down soon. It also threatened to call Justice Huq as a material witness in Sayedee's trial if he does not step aside.
Moudud Ahmed, a former law minister of BNP, and Khandkar Mahbub Hossain, an advisor to BNP chief Khaleda Zia, also argued for Huq's recusal.
The prosecution pointed out that the commission was not among either of the parties to the only case underway at the tribunal and added that the the two parties were the chief prosecutor and the accused, Sayedee.
The defence said that as a member of the secretariat of the enquiry commission Huq was involved in the investigation of war crimes allegations against Jamaat leaders including its chief Motiur Rahman Nizami, secretary general Ali Ahsan Mohammad Mojaheed, Sayedee and BNP leader Salahuddin Quader Chowdhury. Huq was also involved in the process of obtaining statements of witnesses, many of whom are likely to appear before the tribunal to give evidence.
On Oct 30, the war crimes tribunal adjourned Jamaat leader Sayedee's trial until Nov 20 after a heated argument with the defence.
The tribunal head ordered the defence to submit its list of witnesses on Nov 20 when the court would hear opening statements and record witness statements.
Before that, the court would hear a petition on Wednesday to review Sayedee's indictment order of Oct 3.
Charges against Sayedee, who was known as 'Deilla Razakar' in his area during the war, relate to involvement in killing of more than 3,000 unarmed people, rape of over nine women, arson, forcing Hindus to convert their religion, looting and other crimes against humanity. The crimes were committed in Pirojpur district.
Sayedee on Oct 3 denied the accusations brought against him.
Sayedee is the first man facing a formal trial among the five Jamaat leaders and two others from BNP facing similar charges.
He was arrested on July 30 last year. Apart from him, Nizami, Mojaheed and assistant secretaries general Mohammad Kamaruzzaman and Abdul Quader Molla have been arrested on war crimes charges.
Senior BNP leader Salahuddin Quader Chowdhury and Abdul Alim, a minister in Ziaur Rahman's cabinet, have also been arrested on similar charges.
Of the seven Jamaat and BNP leaders facing the war crimes charges, Alim is on conditional bail while the remaining six are behind bars.
bdnews24.com/ta/bd/1323h