November 21, 2026

ICT-1 plunges into chaos

Prosecutors, defence counsels, the witness and the judges shout at each other, Tanim Ahmed was there.

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 21 Oct 2012, 01:52 PM

Updated : 09 Aug 2022, 04:24 PM

Tanim Ahmed Dhaka, Oct 21 (bdnews24.com)—The first war crimes tribunal of Bangladesh broke down into chaos during a cross-examination on Sunday as prosecutors, defence counsels, the witness and the judges shouted at each other. It was supposed to be the last day for cross-examining Misbahur Rahman Chowdhury, the first prosecution witness against Jamaat-e-Islami chief Motiur Rahman Nizami. The three-judge International Crimes Tribunal-1, set up to deal with crimes against humanity during the Liberation War in 1971, indicted the Jamaat chief on Mar 29 for 16 war crimes charges. The chaos was triggered by a question from senior defence counsel Mizanul Islam, who has been leading the war crimes trials of Jamaat leaders at the first tribunal. He had asked the former member of Islami Chhatra Sangha, as the witness claims, the name of the Pakistani Army officer, whether in East Pakistan — latter day Bangladesh — or West Pakistan, who controlled the Al Badr. The Al Badr, along with Razakar and Al Shams vigilante groups, are said to be responsible for widespread atrocities in their bid to thwart liberation efforts in 1971. Motiur Rahman Nizami, as head of Sangha, is said to have led the Al Badr and allegedly masterminded the abduction and murder of intellectuals of Bangladesh days before the Pakistan Army surrendered. The witness answered that the vigilante militia group was politically controlled by Jamaat. The defence counsel objected that the witness was not answering his question and it was settled that the court would record it in a question-answer format instead of the typical narrative format. It was at this point that another defence counsel M Tajul Islam's teasing voice could be heard remarking to his colleagues referring to the witness sitting right in front of him, "We are asking about the military officer and his bringing politics into it!" This got the witness excited and he said, "You have been ridiculing me ever since I came here in the morning." Tajul Islam vehemently denied having insulted the witness. The witness replied in a warning tone, "Don't speak like that to me. I am also into politics." This got Tajul Islam flying into a fit and he kept shouting alternatively addressing the witness and the tribunal. He said he sought protection for having been threatened in front of the court. A former member of Jamaat's student wing, Islami Chhatra Shibir, he said, "I come here as a lawyer and not a Shibir cadre." "I seek the protection of the court," Tajul Islam kept saying and the tribunal Chairman, Justice Mohammad Nizamul Huq indicated that he heard what had been said and said, "Do take your seat." But the defence counsel was not satisfied with this and continued to complain to the tribunal. The witness told the court that the kind of remarks that the counsel was passing were more like a politician than a lawyer. The prosecutors had stood up by this time and began shouting at the defence counsel across the aisle almost entirely drowning out the judges trying to calm the situation. The defence counsels on their part duly reciprocated the prosecutors and told them to quieten down as it was their time with the witness. Defence counsel Mizanul Islam, who almost never loses his cool, was clearly heard shouting back the witness in a very loud, "What is this?" The witness had hardly stopped shouting back at the counsels and at one point he and Tajul Islam were both standing, waving angrily at each other and shouting at the top of their voices. Tribunal member Justice Jahangir Hossain managed to quieten down the witness and also asked Tajul Islam to take his seat. Prosecutor Syed Haider Ali who had stepped out of the court for some time came to find it in middle of the heated quarrel and was the first one to take an actual initiative to placate all the parties. Tempers were running loose among the defence counsel early on in the day. Jamaat chief counsel Abdur Razzaq at one point during the cross-examination of Masood Sayedee, when the tribunal declined to have a reply recorded as it was not in form, told the court, "You are not doing justice." Senior defence counsel Mizanul Islam pointed out to the tribunal that the court had previously recorded explanations and statements of witnesses even if they were asked leading questions and given suggestions. The tribunal in its turn said it was not in form to give an explanation to a leading suggestion that only required either of the two answers — yes it is true, or not it is not. Tribunal Chairman Justice Mohammad Nizamul Huq told Razzaq that his complaint about not getting justice was an old one. "We have been hearing this for long." Razzaq said, "And you will keep hearing it." He sat down without further comments and the tribunal resumed examination of the witness. Later in the day, the tribunal observed that it was the first time Abdur Razzaq put "his language before the tribunal and that is unwarranted". Another defence counsel representing the entire Jamaat leadership at both the war crimes tribunals, Tajul Islam also made similar complaints standing up before the tribunal and in the form of passing remarks on the side sitting with his defence counsels. At a latter point of the day, he said that the tribunal was diverting the witness' answer in reply to which, tribunal member Justice Anwarul Haque went to great lengths to explain that he was merely trying to help with the recording of the witness. The defence counsel had made so many remarks criticising the tribunal rather openly that the prosecutors took serious exception and said that Tajul Islam was insulting the court. The tribunal chose to ignore Tajul's comments for a long time and it was only close to the end of the second session after the chaos had died down, had it said cautioning him, "Do not compel us to take action." Defence counsel Mizanul Islam expressed his inability to continue with the witness cross-examination although the court insisted on it. The court proceedings continued almost until 5pm and the tribunal appeared to be rather adamant to have the cross-examination completed by the end of the day. Earlier, it had delayed lunch by one hour, because Jamaat leader Delwar Hossain Sayedee's son Masood Sayedee's cross-examination had to be completed before it went into recess. The defence was granted another half hour on Monday morning when Misbahur Rahman Chowdhury will take the stand again. bdnews24.com/ta/bd/1943h
Related Stories