HRW crossed a line: Mizanur
The NHRC commissioner says the international rights body's remarks are an 'intrusion' into internal affairs Full report
bdnews24.com News Service
bdnews24.com
Published :
07 Jul 2012, 12:59 PM
Updated :
09 Aug 2022, 03:59 PM
Narayanganj, Jul 7 (bdnews24.com) — The National Human Rights Commission Chairman says Human Rights Watch's report on RAB and BDR mutiny trial is an 'intrusion' into internal affairs of Bangladesh.
"No foreign agency should be telling us that a national force should be dissolved. They should know how far to go, what recommendations are acceptable," Mizanur Rahman told the press at an event on Saturday.
He remarked that the agency had crossed a line.
The HRW report published on July 4 made serious allegations of human rights violations by the elite crime-fighting force Rapid Action Battalion and the trial of mutineer border guards.
The home ministry dubbed the report an 'international conspiracy' and called for its withdrawal.
On human rights violations by RAB vis-a-vis the 2009 BDR mutiny trial, the HRW report said it found at least 47 border guards had died in custody because of 'torture like beatings and electric shocks in custody'. It says the report was made on evidence.
"The mass trials of nearly 6,000 suspects raise serious fair trial concerns," it observed.
The report also recommended disbanding RAB, a hybrid crime-busting unit made up of defence and police personnel that has seen over 600 of its detainees die in, what they call, 'crossfire' in strikingly similar circumstances.
According to the report, the watchdog had interviewed over 60 people, including family members of the victims, prosecutors, defence lawyers and journalists to prepare the report.
"They might be concerned about the human rights situation. But they cannot recommend whether a national force should stay or go," Mizanur said.
Another guest at the event, Sultana Kamal, Executive Director of Ain O Salish Kendra (ASK), said her agency had been raising the issue for a while.
"RAB should work in accordance with its mandate. What we see now is that RAB is working outside its field," she said.
She also remarked that RAB's post-operation press statements were 'unconvincing'.
"But we did not say RAB should be abolished. They must work according to their modus operandi. They have done some good work and they should continue to do so," she added.
The ASK chief said the mutineers must be tried, but it should be a fair trial.
"Mass verdict against 400-500 people in a room … and those who press charges, prosecute and pass verdict are the same people … we say this is against the constitution," she said.
Mizanur and Sultana Kamal later attended a discussion held by the Narayanganj Lawyers' Association.
bdnews24.com/corr/al/sh/nir/1924h