November 20, 2026

HC order based on Facebook

The court asks authorities to answer questions raised by doctor's death after taking cognisance of a Facebook posting.

Staff Correspondent

Sulaiman Neloi,

bdnews24.com

Published : 20 Jan 2013, 05:54 PM

Updated : 23 Apr 2022, 04:00 PM

The High Court’s Sunday order on the death of Doctor Sadia Afrin Iva , that is based on a Facebook posting , has revived the debate whether information on social networking sites could influence legal proceedings.

The bench of Justices Naima Haider and Zafar Ahmed have in their order asked the state and the law enforcing authorities to provide answers to a number of questions raised by Iva’s untimely demise.

The 27-year old lady doctor was found dead on the second floor of the Dakkhinkhan Clinic, run by the country’s top non-governmental organization, BRAC on Dec 1 last year.

Daughter of a police Sub-Inspector Monirul Islam, Iva was an alumni of the Sylhet Medical College.

She was working as a part-time doctor at the Dakkhinkhan clinic , besides pursuing her FCPS at the Sohrawardi Medical College.

Police arrested the clinic’s caretaker Faisal after they found the body.

Deputy Attorney General Md Mokhlesur Rahman said the order was based on a letter, a copy of which was given to the journalists.

The letter contains a posting from lawyer Jessica Irfan’s Facebook profile, which went viral on the Internet site after Iva’s death and finally influenced the High Court’s order.

Written as if they came from Iva, the emotional note posed a number of questions.

“Hadn’t the Brac Dakkhinkhan clinic any responsibility to guard my life and honour? How the law can help my family in this regard?” said one.

Another said: “What is the price of my life? Who will pay the price to my family? Because, it was me who was supposed to look after my aged parents and sister.”

And yet another said: “I was a student of Sylhet Medical College, which celebrated its 50th anniversary after my death. Shouldn’t I expect something from the college? Couldn’t they demand that the government ensures the trial of the killers’? Couldn’t they demand compensation from BRAC?”

And then an appeal to redress gender victimsation: “I am a woman like you, shouldn’t you have written something for me? Who can assure you that your life will not end up like mine tomorrow? Did I myself know what was going to happen to me?”

And then came a question on the role of political parties and women groups: “So many women's orgaisations and political parties hit the streets with numerous demands. They bring out silent processions holding placards. Where were all those as nothing like that happened in my case?”

And finally one for the doctors: “Doesn’t BMA, our (Doctor’s) organisation, where I have been paying my monthly membership fee have any responsibility?”

Deputy Attorney General Rahman said the Inspector General of Police and the Commissioner of Dhaka Metropolitan Police were asked to inform the court about the steps taken following the incident.

BRAC has been asked to explain whether it compensated the victim’s family and what measures they have taken at the clinic to ensure the security of women working there.

The court also asked the Director of NGO Bureau to explain its role in ensuring workplace safety for women at NGOs.

Legal circles in Bangladesh have long been debating whether the higher court can pass an order without any written appeal.

The Bangladesh High Court is known for passing suo moto order.

The country’s leading Constitution expert Mahmudul Islam in the latest edition of his book, Constitutional law of Bangladesh, argued that Article 102 of the Constitution bars the court from passing such an order.

But Barrister Amir Ul Islam, one of the architects of Bangladesh Constitution, has said that despite constitutional restrictions, the court may consider anything as written appeal for the sake of ensuring justice and can pass an order.

Related Stories