Govt to appeal HC ruling on Speaker
Law Minister says the court ruling will be disputed on Monday.
bdnews24.com News Service
bdnews24.com
Published :
30 Aug 2012, 03:34 PM
Updated :
09 Aug 2022, 04:11 PM
Dhaka, Aug 30 (bdnews24.com)—The government has decided to challenge the High Court judgement that declared Speaker Abdul Hamid's ruling 'ineffective and legally unfounded'.
Law Minister Shafique Ahmed said on Thursday that the HC ruling would be contested on Monday, Sept 3.
"We have decided to file an appeal (against the High Court ruling). The Attorney General has been instructed. It may not be possible to lodge the appeal on Sunday, but it will be filed on Monday," he said.
On July 24, the bench of Justices Hasan Faez Siddiqui and ABM Altaf Hossain passed the ruling after hearing a petition calling into question legality of the ruling the Speaker had given in Parliament on July 18.
The full order of the High Court was released on Aug 27, resurrecting the debate over superiority of the Supreme Court and Parliament.
The court in its order observed the Speaker's ruling is non-existent in the eye of law and 'has no legal effect.'
That ruling is not consistent with the Article 96 95) of the constitution and is inconsistent with the parliamentary procedures and the constitution, it had observed
The Speaker had said the comment Justice AHM Shamsuddin Choudhury made criticising the him was derogatory and a violation of the constitution. He also requested MPs to withdraw their proposal for removing the judge.
The ruling was viewed as sensitive enough to douse the tension brewing at that time, threatening the relationship between the court and Parliament.
The HC bench of Justice Choudhury criticised the Speaker for saying in Parliament that the people may stand against Parliament and judiciary if they found decisions taken by these institutions were not right.
The Speaker made the comment on May 29 and on June 5, Justice Choudhury dubbed the statement 'seditious,' drawing flak from MPs.
As the situation got worse with heated arguments exchanged over the authority of the court and Parliament, the Speaker came up with his ruling. In the ruling, he expected that the Chief Justice himself would initiate measures to that end and Parliament would support the decision that he will take.
A lawyer challenged the ruling at the High Court that drew the order in July.
bdnews24.com/sn/eh/bd/2115h