Govt sends pruned rejoinder
The abridged rejoinder has been sent so that The Economist could carry it in its print edition, says a foreign ministry spokesman
bdnews24.com News Service
bdnews24.com
Published :
10 Aug 2011, 07:57 PM
Updated :
10 Aug 2022, 05:15 PM
Dhaka, August 10 (bdnews24.com) – The foreign ministry has issued a shorter version of its earlier rejoinder to The Economist article having adverse comments on Bangladesh, so that the London-based magazine could carry it in its print edition.
The ministry sent a 300-word rejoinder on Tuesday, shortening it from the 1,400-word previous one which the magazine posted on its website under the heading "Our article on Bangladesh and India: The government of Bangladesh responds" on Friday.
"It (the abridged version) has been sent in line with the standard practice of the magazine with regard to the word limit of a rejoinder," said a foreign ministry spokesman, adding The Economist management has promised the foreign office to carry the rejoinder in its next print edition.
The globally-acclaimed magazine in its July 30 issue carried a report titled 'India and Bangladesh: Embraceable You' that narrated 'the growing geopolitical interests of India that force the country to seek better relations closer home'.
However, parts of the article were strongly objected to by the government of Bangladesh.
Foreign minister Dipu Moni trashed the report calling it 'baseless and a pack of lies'. "The report is disgraceful for an internationally-reputed publication like The Economist," an angry minister told bdnews24.com on August 3.
The rejoinder said the government is "disappointed as the report is less than well-researched and contains elements of misinformation and misrepresentation of facts."
The abridged rejoinder, signed by the foreign ministry's external publicity wing's director general Mohammad Shammem Ahsan, termed the article 'disappointing, and totally lacks decency and professional ethics'.
It said the accusation that the Awami League assumed power through "bags of Indian cash and advice" is a blatant lie and a slur to the democracy-loving people of Bangladesh.
Reminding the magazine of its January 3, 2009 report headlined 'The tenacity of hope' that highly appreciated the December 2008 general elections that installed the ruling Awami League to power with three-fourth majority, the rejoinder said the elections were acclaimed internationally 'as the freest-ever in the country, reflecting the aspirations of the people.'
The Economist also endorsed the polls as the "fairest-ever" elections in Bangladesh in the January 3, 2009 issue.
It said the presumption the article expressed that the transit arrangement is intended to create an "Indian security corridor" at the expense of Bangladesh's interests is 'ignorant of the relevant international laws'.
"The arrangement is widely considered a win-win for both countries and the region."
Referring to the weekly's criticism of the 1971 war crimes trial, the 300-word rejoinder said the government's initiative to try the people involved in genocide and war crimes under national and international law 'stems from the norms of any civilised society and is not a vendetta against any political party'.
"It is meant to bring justice to the victims and to end the culture of impunity."
The rejoinder also said the magazine has 'ridiculed' the honour Bangladesh has conferred on Indira Gandhi. "Bangladesh honoured Indira Gandhi for her 'seminal role' during Bangladesh's independence, an honour which you ridiculed," it read.
The rejoinder has protested the manner of raising the issues in the article. "The manner in which you (The Economist) raised the issues indicates that you are carrying out the agenda of a quarter out to launch a smear campaign against Bangladesh and its government."
"Sheikh Hasina, the prime minister, has, through her extraordinary courage, personal sacrifice and inspiring visionary leadership, brought Bangladesh back on track to democratic governance, made it a model for women's empowerment, food security, disaster management and poverty alleviation, and she is pursuing people-centric peace-building policies."
It also said the people in the region are already enjoying the benefits of her (Sheikh Hasina) government's strong stand against terrorism and extremism.
bdnews24.com/nih/nir/2345h