Published : 03 Sep 2012, 10:07 AM
Updated : 09 Aug 2022, 04:12 PM
The government has appealed against a verdict by the High Court that declared 'ineffective' and 'without legal basis' Speaker Abdul Hamid's previous ruling that Justice AHM Shamsuddin Choudhury violated the Constitution by making 'derogatory comment' on parliament.
Chamber Court judge Justice Nazmun Ara Sultana on Monday set the hearing of the plea on Sep 30 at a full bench of the appellate division.
Deputy Attorney General Biswajit Roy had told bdnews24.com in the morning that the Chamber Court might hear the plea filed by Additional Attorney General M K Rahman later in the day.
The two-strong panel of justices Hasan Foez Siddique and ABM Altaf Hossain made the observation on July 24 after a petition sought the court's intervention over the Speaker's June 18 ruling that Justice Choudhury violated Article 78 (1) of the Constitution.
Law Minister Shafique Ahmed said on Aug 30 that they would be contesting the High Court ruling.
"We have decided to file an appeal (against the High Court ruling). The Attorney General has been instructed. It may not be possible to file the appeal on Sunday ... it will be done on Monday," he said.
The full order of the High Court was released on Aug 27, resurrecting the debate as to which one is superior - the legislature or the judiciary.
The court in its order observed the Speaker's ruling was non-existent in the eye of law and 'has no legal effect'. That ruling was not consistent with the Article 96 95) of the Constitution and was also inconsistent with the parliamentary procedures and the Constitution, it had observed
The row began after the Speaker on May 29 made the statement that people might stand up against the judiciary if they were aggrieved by any verdict of the court. It involved an order of the High Court that had asked the Roads and Highways Department to return some land to the Supreme Court.
The High Court bench of Justice Choudhury criticised the Speaker for making that comment that the people could stand up against parliament and judiciary if they found decisions taken by these institutions were not right.
The Speaker made the comment on May 29, and on June 5, Justice Choudhury dubbed the statement 'seditious', drawing flak from MPs.
As the situation got worse with heated arguments exchanged over the authority of the court and parliament, the Speaker came up with his ruling. In the ruling, he expected that the Chief Justice himself would initiate measures to that end and that parliament would support the decision that he would take.
A lawyer had challenged the ruling at the High Court that drew the order in July.