November 21, 2026

Former Pakistan Colonel attacks war crimes trials

A former Pakistan military officer has described Bangladesh’s ongoing war crimes trial a “sham” and said killings, rapes and other human rights violations in the 1971 “political conflict” followed from “internal strife” among Bengali groups.

Senior Correspondent

bdnews24.com

Published : 27 Apr 2014, 10:27 AM

Updated : 19 Oct 2022, 07:28 PM

Writing in the 'Pakistan Observer', retired Colonel M Hanif also questioned the death of three million people and the rape of 200,000 women in 1971, dismissing them as 'hearsay' propogated by the Awami League.

He called Bangladesh’s 1971 war of independence as “Indian engineered separatist struggle” and said India wants “tense relations” between AL and BNP since “Pakistan-Bangladesh relations have been good” in times of BNP governments in Bangladesh.

Hanif now works for the Islamabad Policy Research Institute’ (IPRI), which is known to be close to the Pakistani military establishment.

Headlined “Sham trials in Bangladesh”, Hanif's article apparently praises BNP Chairperson Khaleda Zia for going “so far as to publicly reject the legitimacy of tribunals”.

Citing observations of different global organisations, Hanif observes that the institutional design of the international crimes tribunals “itself creates much suspicion”.

But what would stun many is Hanif's attempt to portray the Pakistan army as innocent -- he claims in the article that it remains “conscious of human rights by not harming civilians or innocent people” in any war.

He said the Awami League (AL) leaders have been asking for trial of Pakistani army officers “on the direction of India” to tarnish Pakistan’s image internationally.

The article also accused AL of “blindly killing and torturing and insulting people to get their cooperation by creating fear of terror” at a time when BNP questioned AL role in 1971. Bangladesh won its independence from Pakistan after a nine-month long bloody civil war in 1971 under the leadership of Awami League. The Jamaat-e-Islami sided with the Pakistan army and joined them in perpetrating horrible atrocities against the Bengalis.

The Jamaat is an ally of the BNP.

The Awami League led government started the war crimes trials after it took power in 2009 to bring to book those responsible for the mass murders and rapes during the 1971 Liberation War.

After the execution of Jamaat's Abdul Quader Molla, Pakistan's Jamaat-e-Islami protested angrily saying he was hanged only because he supported Pakistan army in 1971.

The Pakistan parliament also adopted a resolution after the execution of Molla. Bangladesh officially responded to it by summoning Pakistan’s High Commissioner in Dhaka and asking for non-interference in Bangladesh's "internal affairs".

But retired Colonel Hanif says in his article: "Whatever killings, tortures, rapes and other human rights violations might have taken place in 1971, were mainly the doing of those Bengali groups involved in the conflict with major share of it done by the Awami League activists who were blindly killing and torturing and insulting people to get their cooperation by creating fear of terror”.

“To understand the question of atrocities alleged to be committed in the internal strife in the then East Pakistan in 1971 and Bangladesh (BD) Awami League (AL) government’s politics of recently held trials of alleged war criminals, it is necessary to review the nature of political conflict in 1971 in the then East Pakistan,” he wrote.

“Indian involvement in complicating the political scenario there which led to the Indian engineered separatist struggle started by Awami League activists culminating into Indian attack on the then East Pakistan, in support of Indian trained Awami League separatists, led to formation of Bangladesh”.

He said while AL activists “continue to blame members of Bangladesh Jamaat-i-Islami, Biharis, BNP and Pakistan Army for committing atrocities and talk about conducting their trial, they do not want to try their own fellows who had committed countless atrocities on those Bengali people who were opposing separation from Pakistan”.

“As far as Pakistan Army is concerned, it was initially trying to restore law and order, later it was battling with Indian engineered guerrilla war of Awami League separatists and then it fought war with India.

“In these operations it (Pakistan army) had no concern for people not directly involved in the conflict. It also made serious efforts to avoid collateral damage,” Hanif wrote.

He said the successive governments in Bangladesh since 1972 had “remained silent” on war crimes trial of 1971 “internal strife” mainly to achieve "sustainable internal peace through national reconciliation".

“BNP thinks that hastening of trials in 2013 before general elections was meant to mislead the youth of Bangladesh to get votes and victimize political opponents. “BNP has alleged that the accused were not given a fair trial”. “The fair trial is being denied to the accused by AL government by amending rules and making International Crimes Tribunal Act 1973 too biased,” he wrote. He said AL is also using some “smaller political parties” for registering cases in the International Crimes Court of Justice in Geneva about initiation of trial of some former members of Pakistan army in absentia. “These acts of AL government, not supported by main political parties of Bangladesh, are efforts to breed internal strife in Bangladesh rather than reconciling with the past and working for bright future of the country,” he wrote. “This also indicates that the AL government is not serious in building Bangladesh-Pakistan friendship”. He said it was quite evident that “this is being done on the direction of India since that country wants to tarnish Pakistan’s and its Army’s international image”. “Moreover, India would never like that Pakistan and Bangladesh should have friendly relations”. “It also wants tense relations between AL and BNP since in times of BNP governments in Bangladesh Pakistan-Bangladesh relations have been good”. “Otherwise, it is crystal clear that in the light of 1974 tripartite agreement signed by Pakistan, Bangladesh and India it was mutually agreed that in future, Bangladesh will not raise the issue of trial of former members of Pakistan Army which was deployed in East Pakistan in 1971”. “India also wants that Bangladesh government should remain pliable due to their mutual political tensions,” he wrote.
Related Stories