Flyover had construction flaw: probe
The pillar on the western side of the Khilgaon flyover sank into the ground due to a construction flaw, according to an initial investigation.
bdnews24.com News Service
bdnews24.com
Published :
10 Sep 2011, 02:45 PM
Updated :
10 Aug 2022, 05:25 PM
Dhaka, Sep 10 (bdnews24.com)—The pillar on the western side of the Khilgaon flyover sank into the ground due to a construction flaw, according to an initial investigation.
At a press conference at the Nagar Bhaban on Saturday, professor Monaj Ahmed of the Bangladesh University of Engineering and Technology (BUET), a member of the nine-strong inquiry committee on the incident, briefed reporters about their findings.
A five-member expert delegation visited the flyover on Saturday noon to put their finger on the cause.
"Visual Inspection of the site showed no problem in the pre-stressed girder, deck, elastomeric bearing or pyre. No structural faults were evident."
He added that since local techniques and technology ere used, the construction had not been done with precision.
"We've found nothing in the primary investigation to be panicked about," Prof Ahmed added.
However, Ahmed also suggested keeping the flyover under constant monitoring as a precaution. "If the pillar does not sink any further then repairs will not be needed. But if it does, then it must be fixed."
Asked whether there were problems with the flyover design, the expert said: "There is no relation between the fault and the design. Even the fault is so minor that it cannot be considered a flaw."
He pointed out that only visual inspection was carried out and that further investigations may be done to find out the cause if the city corporation opted for it.
Prof Ahmed claimed that the problem was not created due to maintenance failure and said that the Dhaka City Corporation was not to blame.
"Light-weight vehicles can travel on the flyover now. There should be no issues even if heavier vehicles travel. It is not right that the flyover has not been built for heavy vehicles, they can travel even now," the expert added.
However, DCC chief executive Abul Kalam Azad said that heavy vehicles will be barred from using it, at least for now.
DCC ENGINEERS NOT JOURNALISTS
Dhaka City mayor Sadeque Hossain Khoka in some way admitted the city corporation's failure in being watchful about the state of the flyover.
The blame for the trouble has been laid on the corporation for its alleged failure to maintain the expert-fixed weight ceiling of the passing vehicles.
Almost two kilometres long, the flyover had to be closed to traffic for 17 hours when a pillar sank slightly.
When asked why the engineers did not act beforehand and take necessary measures, a visibly irate mayor said, "The engineers are not like journalists that they will roam around the city all the time."
He added that the flyover was handed over to DCC a year after it was opened to traffic, "Engineers did not find any flaw then."
However, when asked how much was spent on maintenance of the flyover over the last six years, the mayor said, "The engineers have the records, it is impossible to give the estimates immediately. But we have taken enough steps for its maintenance."
'LIGHTER' TRAFFIC RESUMES
After over a 17-hour halt, authorities reopened Khilgaon flyover at 1pm on Saturday, but only for lighter vehicles.
Abul Kalam Azad, the chief executive officer of the Dhaka City Corporation, told reporters that the decision to reopen the flyover for cars and other smaller vehicles came after it was recommended by experts.
The trouble began on Friday night and the vehicular movement was stopped since 8pm after it was noticed that a pillar on the western side of the longest flyover sank some two inches.
'HEAVY' TROUBLE
Haider Ali, the director of the flyover construction project, said on Saturday morning that the pillar sank because of excessive movement of over-weighted heavy vehicles.
After visiting the flyover, he said in the morning that the authorities' failure to stick to the condition that heavy vehicles should not be allowed to ply the flyover actually caused the difficulty
"While handing over the flyover to the DCC in 2005, we told them that the highest weight of a vehicle using the flyover would be 10 tonnes. But over-weighted vehicles ply here regularly," he said.
An iron rod-laden truck weighs 24 tonnes to 27 tonnes, and the movement of such vehicles is common, he said.
The country's second but the longest flyover, constructed under the supervision of the Local Government Engineering Department (LGED), was opened to traffic during the tenure of the BNP-led alliance government on Mar 24, 2005. The local engineers supervised its design and monitored its construction.
It cost Tk 817.5 million to construct the 1.9km long and 14-metre wide flyover.
DCC BLAMED FOR 'LACK OF MAINTENANCE'
Development Construction, the firm which built the flyover, has blamed the DCC's 'lack of maintenance' for the fault.
After visiting the flyover on Saturday, the firm's chief engineer Nurul Amin said, "The city corporation had been handed over charge of the flyover after the construction. But the flyover had not been maintained for a long time. There is no instruction on speed limits of vehicles though we recommended."
He said the damage occurred due to high-speed movement of heavy vehicles.
LGED superintendent engineer Syed Mahbubur Rahman told bdnews24.com that the fault had developed in the past two years.
Pointing to the expansion joints, he said, "These are filled with sand. But there should not be any dust here. The bearings with the pillar have been damaged by the dust."
Senior technical engineer of the construction firm Abdul Hamid also blamed the city corporation for 'not properly maintaining the flyover'.
bdnews24.com/sha/skb/ost/rn/bd/2030h