Defence contests Sayedee raped Bhanu
Mizanul Islam takes tribunal through the prosecution witnesses who mentioned the charge and gives his reasons why the allegation was not substantiated.
bdnews24.com News Service
bdnews24.com
Published :
22 Nov 2012, 02:35 PM
Updated :
09 Aug 2022, 04:32 PM
Dhaka, Nov 22 (bdnews24.com) —On his fifth day of argument Thursday, Delwar Hossain Sayedee's defence counsel challenged the war crimes charge that the Jamaat-e-Islami leader had raped one Bhanu Saha over several months during the Liberation War.
Mizanul Islam took the first war crimes tribunal through the prosecution witnesses who had mentioned the charge in their testimony and gave his reasons why the allegation was not really substantiated.
The three-judge International Crimes Tribunal-1, set up to deal with crimes against humanity during the War of Independence in 1971, indicted the Jamaat executive council member for 20 war crimes charges on Oct 3, 2011.
The 17th charge against Sayedee states that the Jamaat leader, "along with other armed Razakars kept confined [Bipad Saha]'s daughter [Bhanu Saha] at [Bipad Saha]'s house at Parerhat under Pirojpur Sadar Police Station and regularly used to go there to rape her".
Counsel Mizanul Islam went through the testimonies of prosecution witnesses and showed why they did not make a case. He said the fourth prosecution witness Sultan Ahmed Howladar — the only one to have said that Sayedee and Moslem Maulana and others raped Bhanu Saha, and that too in hearsay — had one case against him for stealing bananas pending with the High Court and another of stealing two trawlers pending with a Barisal court .
The counsel said that the witness had said he was not convicted, and pointed out that in one case there was indeed a conviction which he had appealed.
Moreover, the man had admitted that he was not a freedom fighter and had denied a suggestion that the ruling MP of the area had endorsed him as one, while the ruling MP, AKM Awal, who also appeared for the prosecution, said he had indeed endorsed Sultan as a freedom fighter.
The counsel said, "This shows that the witness is of questionable character and cannot be trusted."
He pointed out several times that the witness was merely recounting hearsay.
Tribunal member Justice Anwarul Haque wondered whether the cases had been lodged after Sayedee's war crimes case just to destroy the credibility of the witness. "This may be a point of argument for the prosecution."
Mizanul Islam said that the conviction had apparently come before the case was initiated while the trawler case was also filed before the case. "I don't quite remember if we have made the documents exhibits but we have certainly submitted them."
Then Mizanul Islam swelled on what other prosecution witnesses had said in support of this witness. One had also reported hearsay that Sayedee was said to have been a frequenter of Bipad Saha's house. Others had said that people were known to have visited Bipad Saha's and rape his daughter.
The defence then showed contradiction between the prosecution witnesses and mentioned Ruhul Amin Nabin, the second witness for the prosecution.
"He had given a completely contradictory account and that too after much cajoling."
The defence counsel reminded the tribunal Chairman, Justice Mohammad Nizamul Huq who was the only one of the sitting judges to have been present then — one judge, Justice A T M Fazle Kabir, has become Chairman of the second tribunal while Judge A K M Zaheer Ahmed has resigned — that it was even after the witness had identified Sayedee in the dock that the prosecutor kept asking whether he remembered anything more.
It was then that the man said Pakistani soldiers used to visit Bipad Saha's and rape his daughter for a long time during the war.
The tribunal judges, however, inquired whether Pakistani soldiers frequenting the place automatically precluded the possibility of Sayedee raping the same woman.
The defence counsel said it did not but then said, "But the prosecution case must be specific and definite. It is their allegation."
He then moved to show that the war crimes investigator had admitted during cross-examination that although Bhanu Saha lived abroad the rest of her family were still here.
Mizanul Islam said the most likely witness would be the victim herself and since that was not possible it could have been any other family member. "But he did not make any of her three brothers, their wives or her three sisters a witness."
The next best option would have been a neighbour, said the counsel. "But here we have a casual witness with questionable character who is reporting hearsay."
"I think I have been able to show the tribunal that this charge is baseless and concocted."
Mizanul Islam will resume his argument on Monday (Nov 26).
First case to trial
Sayedee's is the first case to proceed to the trial stage in the war crimes tribunals. The prosecution on Sep 4, 2011 proposed framing of charges against him on 31 counts of crimes against humanity.
The tribunal also sent Jamaat's former chief Ghulam Azam to jail on Jan 11. His indictment hearing began on Feb 15 and the court charged him on May 13.
Jamaat chief Matiur Rahman Nizami, Secretary General Ali Ahsan Mohammad Mujaheed and assistant secretaries general Mohammad Kamaruzzaman and Abdul Quader Molla are also behind bars on war crimes charges. Jamaat financier Mir Quasem Ali was also arrested recently on similar charges as investigation continues into allegations against him.
BNP MP and Standing Committee member, Salauddin Quader Chowdhury, also behind bars, was indicted for 23 charges on Apr 4.
Former BNP lawmaker and minister Abdul Alim is the only one out on bail. All cases have already entered the trial phase.
bdnews24.com/ta/bd/2013h