November 23, 2026

Court rebukes Shahdeen Malik

The High Court has censured lawyer Shahdeen Malik for not providing the press with the truth regarding its clearing two newspapers and seven journalists of contempt of court charges.

Staff Correspondent

bdnews24.com

Published : 14 Mar 2014, 12:42 AM

Updated : 08 Aug 2022, 06:34 PM

Malik at one point, however, admitted his mistake and immediately apologised unreservedly to the court.

The bench of justices Naima Haider and Zafar Ahmed reprimanded the lawyer on Thursday before delivering verdicts on two contempt of court rules against Bengali daily Prothom Alo.

After the court was seated, presiding judge Haider said, “My brother (the other judge) has something to say about published reports regarding the acquittal of journalists.”

Justice Ahmed said, “Prothom Alo published a report yesterday (Wednesday) with the heading ‘Journalists acquitted of contempt of court charges’ regarding exoneration of the journalists. This report started on the first page and ended on page nine.” “At the end of this report it was said that Shahdeen Malik told Prothom Alo after the verdict, ‘The court delivered the verdict after dropping the proceedings. That’s why they (seven journalists) were cleared of the charges’.” The judge asked Malik, “Did you say that they were acquitted after apologising unconditionally?” Malik tried to explain, but the court stopped him. “I don’t want to hear the explanation. Tell me whether you said that or not. You will apologise unconditionally in court but won’t admit that in public. What is this? Now tell me, did you apologise or not?” After the judge asked him several times, he said, “We apologised, my lord. But I could not say it in full since I did not receive the order (in writing).” “Did you mention that (acquittal after apologising unconditionally) or not, tell me that,” the court asked again. Malik answered in the negative. He said there had been a misunderstanding. The judge then said, “Did you carry out your duty as the officer of the court? Your comments in this report will mean that there was no such matter as offering apology on this issue.” “But this (acquittal) happened following the unconditional apology. But it has been misreported here. The misunderstanding is because the entire issue has not been said.” Then Shahdeen Malik said, “I am apologising unconditionally for not understanding the matter.” The bench on Wednesday had cleared Bengali dailies ‘Samakal’, ‘Naya Diganta’ and seven journalists of contempt of court charges after they apologised unconditionally. Lawyer Rokanuddin Mahmud had commented on the media and journalists during a contempt rule hearing against Prothom Alo’s Joint Editor Mizanur Rahman Khan last week. Four journalist bodies – Dhaka Reporters’ Unity (DRU), Dhaka University Journalists’ Association (DUJA), Jagannath University Journalists’ Association (JnUJA) and Barisal Division Journalists’ Association (BDJA) had issued separate statement against Mahmud’s remark last Saturday. They in the statements had demanded expunction of the lawyer’s remarks in court. Dailies Samakal and Naya Diganta had ran reports quoting those statements. The next day, the High Court bench issued a contempt rule against the editors, publisher and printers of both newspapers when Mahmud drew the attention of the judges to the statement. The bench also asked them to appear before it on Wednesday. The seven journalists - DRU President Shahed Chowdhury and General Secretary Ilias Khan, DUJA President MM Jasim and Secretary Saddam Hossain, JnUJA President Kazi Mobarak Hossain and Secretary M Sujaul Hossain and BDJA President Abdur Rahman and General Secretary Ilias Khan - appeared before the court and apologised. Shahdeen Malik accompanied by lawyer Md Monjur Alam had represented the journalists.
Related Stories