Better if Judicial Council impeaches: AG
Attorney general Mahbubey Alam believes there should be a law to impeach Supreme Court judges also for inefficiency alongside misconduct. FULL STORY
bdnews24.com News Service
bdnews24.com
Published :
18 May 2011, 11:38 AM
Updated :
10 Aug 2022, 04:49 PM
Dhaka, May 18 (bdnews24.com)—Attorney general Mahbubey Alam believes there should be a law to impeach Supreme Court judges also for inefficiency alongside misconduct.
It will be easier for the Supreme Judicial Council, if empowered, to impeach judges, he said at a programme organised to welcome the new chief justice on Wednesday.
At present, there is provision to impeach judges only for professional misconduct
Speaking at a reception accorded to Justice Mohammad Muzammel Hossain, Alam said everybody is waiting to see whether parliament or the Supreme Judicial Council will impeach the judges.
If the power lies with parliament, he argued, the judge in question will continue to damage the judiciary if parliament does not have a two-thirds majority to remove him from office.
But the Supreme Judicial Council can move to act quickly once it receives complaints, the top law officer of the state added.
"I appeal to the members of parliament and you that not only misconduct but inefficiency is also be added as offences that call for impeachment."
"Does (a judge) who cannot write standard verdict and dispose of a reasonable number of cases has the right to cling to a constitutional post?" he questioned.
Immediate-past chief justice A B M Khairul Haque on Tuesday said parliament can make law to impeach judges as e believed judges too should be held to account.
During a discussion with the special committee on charter review on Apr 27, prime minister Sheikh Hasina said parliament should be authorised to impeach judges.
She had asked, "If parliament can impeach the president, who appoints judges, why can't it impeach the judges?"
In its broadest sense, impeachment is the process by which public officials may be removed from office on the basis of their conduct.
Strictly speaking, it is the decision by a legislature to accuse an official of one or more offenses that warrant removal according to constitutional standards. A vote to impeach then triggers a trial based on those charges. Parliament initiates resolutions to impeach a sitting president.
In June 21, 2002, president A Q M Badruddoza Chowdhury resigned after being compelled with the possibility of impeachment and removal from office by the BNP-led parliament on charge of disrespecting BNP founder Ziaur Rahman.
ACCOUNTABILITY OF JUDGES
Alam said, "Many judges say they are accountable to their conscience. I think it's an airy-fairy remark."
He asked the new chief justice, "Can't this organisation (Supreme Court) monitor how many cases a judge of a single bench settles a month? Won't you apply your powers as a chief justice in this regard?
"Would you remain silent preferring to overlook how many cases are disposed of by a division bench or if the verdicts met standards?"
INVESTIGATE CORRUPTION
Recalling the reception of Justice Tafazzal Islam as chief justice, the chief legal officer said Justice Islam spoke about corruption in the judiciary.
"Later an investigation committee was formed that submitted a report. But nothing happened afterwards."
He expressed his hope that Justice Muzammel would take steps in this regard.
NO COMPROMISE
Alam said, "These days, 'some' High Court judges speak scornfully about the work of the Appellate Division judges.
"Especially many benches of the High Court are not properly following Supreme Court orders on anticipatory bail.
"I believe that you won't compromise in this issue," Alam said, gesturing at the top judge.
He said the High Court judges are bound to be faithful to the Appellate Division in much the same way that lawyers are loyal to the court rules.
MONEY THE SPOILER
"No one keep the proverb 'money is the source of all evil' in mind now. Most of the lawyers go after money," Alam said.
"All the chaos in courts stem from the craving for money by ignoring morality."
bdnews24.com/corr/jk/ach/ost/bd/1956h