November 21, 2026

Apologetic Muhith retracts Hallmark remark

Under-fire from Treasury Bench MPs, Finance Minister says his statement could have encouraged corruption Full story

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 06 Sep 2012, 03:07 PM

Updated : 09 Aug 2022, 04:13 PM

Dhaka, Sep 6 (bdnews24.com)—Finance Minister AMA Muhith regretted his remarks that the loan given to the Hallmark Group by Sonali Bank was nothing and retracted it during his speech in Parliament on Thursday. "Tk 40 billion is nothing - this statement has caused misunderstanding. My statement may encourage corruption. I did not mean to encourage the scamsters by any means. So, I regret to have made the speech and am withdrawing it," said Muhith. Muhith had said on Sep 4 that given Bangladesh's Tk 400-billion portfolio of commercial bank loans, the Hallmark sum was tiny and that it would in no way affect the entire banking system. He also commented that there was no need for such hullabaloo in the media over the Hallmark scam since Tk 40 billion was not a big deal for the government. On another occasion, Muhith also commented that the central bank did not have the authority to recommend action against Sonali Bank officials after Bangladesh Bank had advised that the government sack the Sonali Bank's board. The statement was withdrawn a day after Treasury Bench MPs derided him over the comment and suggested that the minister had better talked less. In the morning, the minister baited the senior Awami League MPs and declined comment on issues when journalists approached him. The minister has been under fire lately after the World Bank pulled out of the Padma bridge project and after it emerged that officials of the largest state-run commercial bank had violated rules in disbursing over Tk 36 billion loans to six institutions, including textile firm Hallmark. Muhith declared in Parliament that the government was indeed intent about eliminating the root of the recent Hallmark scam that has rocked Bangladesh. He said the government was taking necessary initiatives to identify and bring the perpetrators to justice. Muhith's initial remarks in Parliament apparently defending the Sonali Bank board set off a round of fiery replies from senior Treasury Bench members. Former commerce minister Abdul Jalil, former industries minister Tofail Ahmed, former law minister Abdul Matin Khasru and Workers Party President Rashed Khan Menon blasted the bank's board of directors. Some of them demanded tougher action and asked why stronger action was not being taken other than suspending and withdrawing certain officials. Muhith had to take the floor a second time afterwards and replied to queries of his colleagues. Regarding questions whether the government was also involved, Muhith said he believed that no-one of his ministry was involved. "However, if the investigations prove to the contrary, there will be appropriate measures." As for the general demand of arresting involved officials, the Finance Minister reassured his colleagues that the government was indeed thinking about it. "Do have patience. Let the investigation come to a close." Muhith in his initial statements touched upon certain points regarding what he said was being referred to as the Hallmark scandal. The Hallmark Group, along with other organisations had secured Tk 40 billion worth of loans through forged documents from the Ruposhi Banngla Hotel Branch of Sonali Bank, which is the largest state-owned bank in Bangladesh. He said that the scam was first detected in a Bangladesh Bank audit in 2010. Subsequently, he said Sonali Bank submitted "two false reports". "None of those reports went to the Board of Directors." Muhith said the board was only aware of a loan of Tk 650 million given to the Hallmark Group. "But they exploited this sanction and engaged in large scale fraud." A following internal investigation as well as one by the central bank found irregularities. Bangladesh Bank had recommended that those involved in the fraud be punished. Sonali Bank then undertook a measure, which is generally the course of action across the world. "And it was the first ever such action in Bangladesh, which is functional audit." That report came out on July 13, he said, reminding Parliament that such reports were never made public at the outset. "It is only so that the bank may get the people behind this to admit their fraud and once that is done it tries to get back its money." To do so, the Finance Minister went on to explain, the bank asks for collateral against the loan. "Because it is only by leveraging the collateral that the bank may get back its money." He said, "Generally all this is kept very secret. But the secrecy was not maintained in this case. There is some good and some bad in all this." "The good thing," said Muhith, "Was that the entire nation has become aware and demands justice so that such a scam does not recur." "As for actions," the minister said, "it is not that there have not been any. We have already withdrawn two deputy managing directors), suspended 19 officials and sacked two others." He pointed out that action against such high officials as DMDs, who rank right below the bank's boss, was heretofore unheard of in Bangladesh. He then indicated his two frontbench MPs sitting next to him who had said, 'the less the Finance Minister speaks the better', and said, "There are two members here who have advised me to speak less, and I don't want to speak much." There was a show of hands as soon as he sat down and Speaker Abdul Hamid acknowledged Abdul Jalil, who also happens to be the Chairman of a commercial bank. He said, "I am involved with a commercial Bank. How can the board not be aware of such transactions?" He demanded a statement from the Finance Minister on this matter. Abdul Matin Khasru said, "This has become the talk of the country now. The matter was detected in 2010, then why was there no action?" Damaging the goodwill of an institution like the Sonali Bank in such a manner is not a matter of joke, he said. He suggested that the perpetrators be interrogated as to how they got around to get such a loan. Tofail was in the middle of his deliberations when the Prime Minister joined the session. The Hallmark Group's loan was detected and Sonali Bank was informed about the matter too, according to the central bank. "Bangladesh Bank cannot be held responsible for the time lapse." "But the board cannot evade its responsibility in this regard." Tofail asked the Finance Minister, "But why has the Chairman not been removed. The board is appointed by the government. And removing the Chairman would also be perceived as some form of action." "But if the board remains then the entire responsibility falls upon the government's shoulders. I have stood up only to clarify this issue." Rashed Khan Menon, whose Workers Party is currently a government ally, and who heads the Parliamentary Standing Committee on the Ministry of Education, began by thanking the Finance Minister for his remarks. "But there has to be a concrete statement in this regard." He said, "So we know that the board only knew about Tk 650 million loans but what about the rest of the money? Who was behind that?" Menon also demanded that the government investigate whether board was itself involved in the matter. Muhith then stood up to defend the board of directors and reassured his colleagues that it had been reconstituted with just three members including the Chairman. "It is the board that has initiated the probe, not the bank management." Muhith said there has to be a board on top for the bank to run and the investigation to complete. "And its tenure will come to an end on Sep 9 anyway." He then said, "I am perhaps the most hated person in this country, but I have no complaints regarding that. People are perfectly within their rights to hate me." The minister then went on that this scam had not in anyway rocked the banking sector. "The health of the financial sector is fine, so is that of the economy." He also agreed with Khasru and said that Sonali Bank was indeed a very important financial institution for the country and indicated that the government was taking necessary measures. bdnews24.com/ta/ssz/mhc/sum/eh/bd/2223h

Related old stories

• Muhith, 'syndicate' blamed

Related Stories