November 23, 2026

'Ambiguity' resurfaces over SC verdict review scope

The ambiguity that prevailed after the final verdicts on two earlier war crimes cases over the scope for filing a review petition against the Appellate Division's judgment has once again surfaced.

Suliman Niloy Suliman Niloy

bdnews24.com

Published : 03 Nov 2014, 05:16 PM

Updated : 08 Aug 2022, 07:18 PM

The four-strong Appellate Division bench headed by Justice Surendra Kumar Sinha upheld former Al-Badr commander Mohammad Kamaruzzaman's death sentence, for war crimes committed in 1971, on Monday.

On May 9 last year, the war crimes tribunal awarded death to Jamaat’s assistant secretary general, who was the chief of the vigilante militia in greater Mymensingh region at the time of the Liberation War.

The state says that there's no scope for reviewing the verdict.

Speaking to reporters on Monday, Attorney General Mahbubey Alam said: “I don’t think there is a scope to file a review petition. The court rejected the review petition filed by (Abdul) Quader Molla. So there is no chance for that anymore.”

Asked whether Section 105 of the Constitution can provide a provision for a review, he said, “The trials are being held under special laws, protected by the Constitution. Section 105 did not apply to Quader Molla, and I will say the same in this case."

The section says the Appellate Division has the power to review any of its own judgment.

In regular cases, the defence can file for a review of the Appellate Division's verdict upon finding a new legal ground.

Alam, the country's top legal official who represented the state against Kamaruzzaman's appeal, said the defence might have various kinds of pleas and those may or may not have any legal grounds.

The defence, however, says it will appeal for a review.

“Review is a constitutional right. The prosecution has been saying that a review isn’t possible. But there was a review in Quader Molla’s case.

“We’ll file a review, and there will be a hearing and the judges then can decide either way. It can be scrapped if it is not sustainable,” Kamaruzzaman's lawyer Tajul Islam told reporters after the verdict.

He, however, said the sentence could not be executed 'without giving a chance for review'.

The ambiguity over the review first surfaced when the Supreme Court awarded death sentence to war criminal Molla.

Molla's lawyer sought a review for the verdict as well as acquittal.

The petition had prompted a last-minute postponement of Molla's execution. But after two days of hearing, both pleas were rejected and he was hanged on Dec 12 last year. During the hearings, the state argued that war crimes trials in different countries had no provision for appeals, but in Bangladesh there was such a provision and hence the defence could file one against Molla's tribunal verdict. But since the war crimes law has stated nothing about a review, so it is not maintainable. The defence argued, referring to other cases, that it had the right to do so. Kamaruzzaman's final verdict has once again triggered the same debate.
Related Stories