US-Libya ties may improve if medics are set free
Libya's ties with the United States would improve if it freed six foreign medics accused of infecting Libyan children with HIV but this may not trigger any quick, tangible benefits to Tripoli, analysts said on Monday.
bdnews24.com News Service
bdnews24.com
Published :
18 Dec 2006, 06:00 PM
Updated :
17 Aug 2022, 07:04 PM
WASHINGTON, December 19 (bdnews24.com/Reuters) - Libya's ties with the United States would improve if it freed six foreign medics accused of infecting Libyan children with HIV but this may not trigger any quick, tangible benefits to Tripoli, analysts said on Monday.
A Libyan court is expected to rule on Tuesday on the fate of five Bulgarian nurses and a Palestinian doctor charged with deliberately infecting 426 children at a hospital in Benghazi in the late 1990s. The prosecution demands the death penalty.
The medics, who deny the charges, were convicted in a 2004 trial and sentenced to death by firing squad. But the Libyan supreme court quashed the ruling last year and ordered the case be returned to a lower court.
While saying the outcome is impossible to predict, analysts said the most likely scenario for the retrial would be that the convictions would be confirmed but that the six may eventually be pardoned and sent home.
A senior U.S. official stressed that the verdict will not be the final step in the Libyan legal process, saying it can be appealed to the Libyan supreme court and could then go to the Libyan "higher judicial council," which could grant clemency.
Even if the six eventually go free, analysts did not expect a quick US response because of outstanding issues like the 1986 bombing of a German disco used by U.S. servicemen and the 1988 Lockerbie bombing, which the West blamed on Libya.
"It certainly helps," David Mack of the Washington-based Middle East Institute, who visited Libya earlier this month, said of the effect a release of the nurses and the doctor may have on U.S.-Libyan relations.
Ties improved dramatically after Tripoli's 2003 decision to give up weapons of mass destruction, with Washington removing economic sanctions, dropping Libya from its list of state sponsors of terrorism and resuming diplomatic relations.
However, two steps Washington has not taken are exchanging ambassadors or sending the US secretary of state to visit Tripoli.
"I am not sure that just resolving the Bulgarian nurses case would do it," Mack added, suggesting a settlement over the 1986 bombing at a West Berlin disco that killed three people and injured more than 200 may be more important to Washington.
Libya has not agreed to compensate victims of that attack. While it reached a settlement to pay families of the Lockerbie bombing victims $10 million per victim, it has yet to pay out the final $2 million each the families believe they are owed.
US Assistant Secretary of State David Welch visited Libya on Friday and Saturday to discuss ties and, in particular, the case of the Bulgarian nurses and the Palestinian doctor, whom the U.S. government wants to see released.
A senior U.S. official said whatever the court may decide on Tuesday, the case may go to the Libyan supreme court or ultimately to the "higher judicial council," which could reduce the lower court's sentences or grant clemency.
"Those are all options in front of them. I don't want to forecast which might be taken, but the point is there are several different layers in this process -- whereas many may read tomorrow's verdict as the final statement on the issue," said the official, who spoke on condition he not be named.
"The key thing here is it (Tuesday's verdict) is not the end of the process," he added. "The message the Libyans have given to us is for us to be patient, to allow this to go through to its conclusion, and not to jump to any conclusions from what may happen tomorrow."
bdnews24.com/mi/1131 hrs.