November 21, 2026

No breakthroughs seen in India, Pakistan talks

India and Pakistan will meet this week for broad talks on their peace process but no breakthroughs are expected on major territorial disputes between the nuclear-armed neighbours.

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 12 Mar 2007, 09:43 AM

Updated : 17 Aug 2022, 02:39 PM

ISLAMABAD, March 12 (bdnews24.com/Reuters) - India and Pakistan will meet this week for broad talks on their peace process but no breakthroughs are expected on major territorial disputes between the nuclear-armed neighbours. The talks between top foreign ministry officials come as Pakistan is preoccupied with its western border and US pressure to stop militant raids into Afghanistan. At the same time, India had little incentive to make concessions, Pakistani analysts said. "Frankly, I don't expect any spectacular outcome," said former Pakistani foreign secretary Shamshad Ahmed Khan. The two sides will sit down on Tuesday in Islamabad for the fourth round of a so-called composite dialogue since they launched a peace process in 2004. The talks cover all issues including the main dispute over the divided Kashmir region. India has given a cold shoulder to Pakistani President Pervez Musharraf's suggestions the Muslim-majority Himalayan region, where insurgents have been fighting security forces on the Indian side since 1989, be demilitarised and come under some form of joint management. Levels of infiltration by militants from Pakistan into Indian Kashmir have fallen in the past three years after international pressure on Pakistan to rein in the guerrilla groups. At the same time, the regular exchanges of fire across the line separating India and Pakistan in Kashmir have stopped since late 2003. "The Kashmir situation now is what India had always wanted, with Pakistan being beaten by the anti-terrorism stick and the movement of the insurgency, or militancy, drastically down," said Pakistani political analyst and newspaper columnist Ajaz Amir. "This is a process very much on Indian terms." With no breakthrough seen on Kashmir, attention has focused on two other territorial disputes -- the Siachen Glacier, an icy wasteland the two armies have fought over since the 1980s, and Sir Creek, a border estuary flowing into the Arabian Sea. "These are the two issues on which there can be an agreement, but I doubt if there will be," Amir said. "Pakistan is preoccupied by the western border, by Afghanistan, by the ramifications of the American connection, or American pressure, and then by the way we've shot ourselves in the foot regarding the chief justice," Amir said, referring to uproar over a government decision last week to suspend the country's top judge. "I doubt if India would be interested in moving forward when Pakistan has plunged itself into another self-created crisis." Ajai Sahni of the New Delhi-based Institute for Conflict Management also said he expected little of substance. "Basically, it's all posturing for the international community. Both countries need to engage the international community to get certain benefits; basically it's about ensuring Western support for their countries continue," Sahni said. Despite the low expectations, the little agreements, and the talking itself, were important, analysts said. "Breakthroughs only come after the success of small, incremental measures," said Sukh Deo Muni, a South Asia expert at New Delhi's Jawaharlal Nehru University. "Dialogue always has a silver lining. At least it keeps the tensions low, it prevents the risk of confrontation, the two parties remain engaged in a constructive process," Khan said. bdnews24.com/mi/1450 hrs.
Related Stories