Estonia still dealing with its Russian legacy
Look up from the medieval Old Town square of Estonian capital Tallinn and one of the first sights that grabs the eye is a large Russian Orthodox Cathedral.
bdnews24.com News Service
bdnews24.com
Published :
28 Feb 2007, 01:37 PM
Updated :
17 Aug 2022, 02:32 PM
TALLINN, February 28 (bdnews24.com/Reuters) - Look up from the medieval Old Town square of Estonian capital Tallinn and one of the first sights that grabs the eye is a large Russian Orthodox Cathedral.
The domes and elaborate Byzantine architecture are a contrast to the cool, white walls of an Estonian Lutheran cathedral nearby, but serve as a reminder of the long history of domination of Estonia by its large Russian neighbour.
As Estonia nears parliamentary elections on March 4, that history has invaded the present.
Estonia and Russia are embroiled in a dispute over a Soviet-era war memorial, which nationalist politicians want removed. Russia has said this would be "blasphemy" to the memories of those who fought fascism in World War II.
Another legacy of the Russian era -- which extends from the Tsarist days when the Orthodox cathedral was built to the 50 years of post-World War II Soviet rule -- is a Russian-speaking minority still trying to find its place in the new Estonia.
Nina, who, like many people in this part of the world does not want to give her last name when questioned by reporters, said life for her was normal. "There are no problems," she said as she left the Russian cathedral on a snowy afternoon.
However, when pressed, she echoed complaints often heard among the roughly 300,000 Russian-speakers left in Estonia after the collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991.
She resents the lack of an automatic right to citizenship and the need to pass language exams to become a citizen.
"To get Estonian citizenship we need to know the constitution and pass language exams and there are checks on this. It costs money to take language courses and there are checks on this knowledge," she said.
"I have a 20-year-old son and he was born in Estonia and he does not have Estonian citizenship and he should have it."
DISCRIMINATION?
When Estonia regained its independence after five decades of what it describes as Soviet occupation, it only recognised the citizenship claims of those who had been citizens in 1940, when Soviet forces first marched in, and their descendants.
So while Estonians automatically received citizenship and the right to vote, most Russian-speakers had to go through a naturalisation process, including Estonian language exams.
Most of the Russian minority came during the Soviet era and had little need of Estonian, a Finno-Ugric language very unlike Russian, a fact which has become a problem after independence.
Roughly a third of Russian-speakers have naturalised, a third took citizenship of the Russian Federation and a third live on aliens' passports, with the right to reside.
Russia has long claimed Estonia is guilty of discrimination, charges Tallinn denies. It has said it has eased the citizenship path for children and actively works to boost integration.
However, Amnesty International raised the issue in December in one of the harshest reports on Estonia in years. It said Russian-speakers often found themselves de facto excluded from the labour market and education system.
In a follow-up letter on Feb. 27, Amnesty also urged Estonia to curb the activities of the Language Inspectorate, which it called repressive and punitive.
The inspectorate was created to ensure that minimum language requirements are met and can make unannounced raids.
BRONZE SOLDIER
With Estonian lawmakers proposing several pieces of legislation in recent months that Moscow sees as anti-Russian, existing tensions between the countries have worsened.
The war memorial, a bronze statue of a lone soldier looking mournfully down at the ground, has become a particular irritant.
Nationalists in parliament, backed by the Reform Party of Prime Minister Andrus Ansip, passed legislation to get the statue moved to a cemetery from the centre of town, seeing it as a reminder of Soviet rule.
However, President Toomas Ilves, linking the move to the feverish pre-election atmosphere, vetoed the bill.
Where all this has left the sentiments of Russian-speakers ahead of the election is not clear.
Andrei Zarenkov leads the main political party focussed on Russian-speakers, the Constitution Party, which has failed in four elections to win any seats.
"Last time many people did not come to vote, they are tired of believing that something will change. This time we hope that we will get into parliament," he told Reuters.
Perhaps symbolic of Russian-speakers' sentiments on the vote is Gennady, who again declined to give his last name as he cleared snow from around the cathedral.
"No, I don't speak Estonian, only Russian ... I don't know if I can vote or not," he said.
bdnews24.com/amt/1925 hrs.