Nizami's case transfer plea rejected
ICT-1 also turns down appeal for a review of his charges in the indictment order
bdnews24.com News Service
bdnews24.com
Published :
27 Jun 2012, 04:53 PM
Updated :
09 Aug 2022, 03:56 PM
Tanim Ahmed
Dhaka, Jun 27 (bdnews24.com) — The first war crimes tribunal of Bangladesh rejected two applications of Jamaat-e-Islami chief Matiur Rahman Nizami, one of them for transfer of the case to the second tribunal and another appealed for a review of Nizami's charges in the indictment order.
Set up to try crimes against humanity during the 1971 Liberation War, the three-judge International Crimes Tribunal-1, indicted the Jamaat chief on 16 charges on May 28.
Nizami sought to transfer his case to the second tribunal questioning the tribunal chairman's impartiality and stating that there was reasonable ground to presume bias of the tribunal Chairman Justice Mohammad Nizamul Huq.
As an alternative, the application, in effect, asked that the tribunal chief remove himself. The defence, which consists of almost the same group of lawyers representing the entire Jamaat leadership, had filed similar applications in the cases against two other Jamaat leaders — once in Delwar Hossain Sayedee's case and the second time in Jamaat's former chief Ghulam Azam's case.
The tribunal gave its observation on both transfer and recusal of the judge with Justice Huq reiterating the points the court had made on the two previous occasions. The judge said regarding his recusal on the grounds of impartiality that the burden of proof was upon the accused petitioner since the office of the judge presumes impartiality.
However, the judge noted that the defence had not been able to present anything which proved that the judge had indeed lost his independence and impartiality.
Justice Huq cited the case where Sam Hinga Norman appealed for the recusal of Justice Renate Winter at the Special Court of Sierra Leone. Apparently the Appeals Chamber had received a brief from UNICEF and Judge Winter had previously been acknowledged in UNICEF publications addressing the isue of child soldier recruitment as having assisted with the preparation of those reports. However, the application was turned down.
The defence had also mentioned that Dr Asif Nazrul, an expert in international river law, had stated on a television talk show that the Justice Huq should recuse himself given his prior involvement with a people's enquiry commission where he supposedly investigated alleged crimes against humanity. As such, the judge had compromised his impartiality.
The tribunal rejected the petition saying, "The application does not merit any consideration and thus stands rejected."
Regarding the review of Nizami's indictment and application for expunging certain parts of the order, Justice Huq noted three of the points made by the defence and reiterated the points he had previously made in the case of Ghulam Azam's indictment which also saw a similar application.
The tribunal chairman said that the indictment order was in no way conclusive but merely "indicated the contentious issues". He said noting the defence's reservations that the indictment order's points could either be proved or disproved only after the trial with the admission of all the evidence.
Furthermore, the defence would have every opportunity to disprove the charges upon which Nizami would be duly acquitted of those charges.
The defence had contested a point in one of the charges which said that the Jamaat chief had assisted the then Jamaat guru Ghulam Azam in founding the Peace Committee, and other vigilante groups like Razakar, Al Badr and Al Shams which actively engaged with the Pakistan Army to thwart the liberation forces.
The tribunal observed that it was a fact that Nizami, being head of Jamaat's student wing assisted Azam, then the Jamaat chief of East Pakistan, in all party initiatives.
The tribunal said that it found no reason to deviate to expunge certain portions, as appealed for by the defence, of the indictment order and rejected the petition.
The Jamaat chief was indicted on 16 charges crimes against humanity on May 28.
bdnews24.com/ta/bd/2145h