MPs strike back at TIB over report
MPs demand the TIB Executive Director and officials are summoned and the anti-corruption watchdog's operations stopped.Full Report
bdnews24.com News Service
bdnews24.com
Published :
19 Nov 2012, 02:59 PM
Updated :
09 Aug 2022, 04:31 PM
Dhaka, Nov 19 (bdnews24.com)— Transparency International, Bangladesh (TIB) on Monday faced a rash of criticism from the Members of Parliament for its recent assessment report on their activities.
In a staccato burst of protests, they asked that the officials and Executive Director of the Berlin-based anti-corruption watchdog's Dhaka office be summoned during ongoing session.
The MPs also sought a ban on TIB operations.
Speaker Abdul Hamid also joined the fusillade of criticism and doubted the TIB report's authenticity during the unscheduled discussion.
A TIB research published on Oct 14 said that 97 percent MPs were involved in 'negative activities', evaluating works of 149 MPs – 136 from ruling Awami League and 13 from the opposition, including 27 Ministers and State Ministers.
The report said that the MPs influence administration, control educational institutes, misappropriate development fund and even back criminal activities. It also said that the MPs influence the administration's procurement decision, break electoral rules, and in many cases provide false information to get plots.
Awami League MP Sheikh Fazlul Karim Selim initiated the discussion in the evening and several others followed suit.
Speaker Hamid brought an end to the discussion for the day suggesting TIB pin down the errors of the MPs, but not make wholesale blames.
"We are humans, not angels. We do make errors. Please specify. Then we can correct ourselves."
After hearing the MPs, Hamid said Parliament would be notified about the decision over the issue after discussions with the senior MPs.
Earlier, MP Selim, also a Presidium member of the ruling party, demanded shutting down all TIB activities.
As more MPs sought floor to speak on the matter, the Speaker said, "I understand you sentiment. But I cannot give floor to everyone to speak now."
Most of the ruling Grand Alliance MPs, who joined the discussion, expressed 'surprise' over TIB's method to prepare the report by taking opinions only from 600 people among the nearly 160 million in the country.
They also suspected that there might be a hidden agenda behind publishing the report only a year before the next parliamentary elections.
Awami League's Advisory Council member Tofail Ahmed said, "Summon the TIB (officials). Ask them what information they have. Call a meeting of the Privilege Committee. Ask for the information from those who submitted the report."
MPs also supported his call to summon the TIB officials by thumping the table.
Tofail said, "TIB has done an unethical act by taking opinions only from 600 people among the 160 million. TIB has no right to do that this way."
He said releasing this sort of report before the next elections was motivated. "You, me... we all do politics. We are experienced people. And you [TIB] published this report only a year before the elections."
Sheikh Selim alleged that TIB was plotting to make Parliament dysfunctional by assassinating the character of the MPs.
"They [TIB] were looking for their favourable people in various districts after 1/11. Deposits of the most them were forfeited. Most of them did not even run in the elections out of fear. Now they are trying to create a third force as their Minus Two theory did not work out. But the people of Bangladesh will not let that happen."
Criticising the TIB suggestion to enact a law to 'prevent the negative activities of the MPs', Selim said, "You [TIB] want to make a law? You have to come to Parliament to formulate a law. Who are they? They don't have any relation with the people."
"Many NGO officials live a luxurious life. I would like to ask ACC to keep an eye on them. TIB considers itself a superpower. They are crossing the line," he ranted.
The ruling party MP also urged Parliament to summon the anti-graft watchdog's top-brass and the Anti-Corruption Commission to investigate assets of the TIB officials.
Jatiya Party's Mujibul Haque said, "TIB had invited me [to a programme]. I had asked them to send me an account of where they got the money from to pay for the venue and food. But they have not sent that yet."
"I challenge– Iftekharuzzaman (TIB Executive Director) won't be able to respond. And you will publish this report before the election – this is motivated and conspiratorial," he said.
Jatiya Samajtantrik Dal's Shah Jikrul Ahmed said: "Present the income tax documents of the NGO workers, those who prepared the report and the 600 people who participated in the survey."
"I'll give my income tax documents too. If there is any discrepancy, I'll resign."
Awami League MP Tarana Halim criticised the opposition BNPs position on the issue.
Another ruling party MP Subid Ali Bhuiyan said, "There are some quarters in our country who say anything they want. This is not freedom of speech. By doing so, they are tainting our characters."
However, ruling party MP Nurul Islam Sujon said the people were insulted through the TIB report while another MP Nazam Akter said, "We are rejecting this report."
Speaker Hamid said, "TIB prepared and gave the report on 97 percent of the MPs. But they did not even go to 97 percent places."
"They chose 600 people, who are they? Are these people their [TIB] employee or from any party?"
"The ruling party is not good, the opposition is no better. Then who will run the country? Is it TIB? Take part in the election, if the people puts them in power, then everything will be positive," Hamid said.
bdnews24.com/mhc/sum/trb/bd/2134h