November 21, 2026

A broken country called Afghanistan

A broken country called Afghanistan
Former Mujahideen hold weapons to support Afghan forces in their fight against Taliban, on the outskirts of Herat province, Afghanistan July 10, 2021. Reuters

Syed Badrul Ahsan Syed Badrul Ahsan

Published : 11 Jul 2021, 01:35 AM

Updated : 21 Jun 2022, 08:17 PM

No one has been able, down the centuries, to tame Afghanistan. But everyone has had a hand in contributing to its destruction, piece by piece.

Afghanistan, for all its pride and its refusal to surrender to foreign powers and internal subversion, is today a broken country. One can be sure that as the Taliban advance toward Kabul in what will likely be a second takeover by them of the country, there will be more deaths and more wounds. The mountains will bring forth fresh new gunfire. Towns and cities will lapse into fear again. Tribes will explore, yet again, the means of how best and how soon to subdue one another.

It did not have to be this way. Had Sardar Mohammad Daoud Khan, a wily politician and relative of King Zahir Shah, not decided to overthrow the monarch and seize the country in 1973, Afghanistan would be a fairly peaceful place, with its men learning about the world beyond their country, with its women, enlightened and modern, educating themselves in universities. In the late 1960s and early 1970s, Afghanistan was a beautiful country of beautiful people.

The coup d'etat by Sardar Mohammad Daoud in 1973 was a precursor to the trouble that lay ahead. Daoud tried putting a republic in place, albeit under his authoritarian rule. It did not work, for within five years, he was dead with his family. The country's communists, straddling factions known as Khalq and Parcham, commandeered power, believing that they were putting a socialist system, along the lines of the Brezhnev version of it in the Soviet Union, in place. The poet and certainly a good communist, Nur Mohammad Taraki, took charge of Afghanistan.

The manner of the communist rise in the country was flawed. Revolutions are never imposed from the top. Communism, as Mao Zedong and his colleagues in China were to prove conclusively, necessarily is a matter of indoctrination of people in the rural interior of a country. Communism is unalloyed political faith and once that lesson is imbibed by a people, the times are ripe for revolution. That faith in communism was missing in Afghanistan. When Taraki and his fellow leftists removed Daoud in the so-called Saur Revolution in 1978, they only succeeded in doing a coup. Revolution was missing.

And because communism in Afghanistan remained confined to the Khalq and Parcham factions, Taraki soon collapsed, done to death by his fellow communists led by Hafizullah Amin. And then Amin was put out of life when the Soviet Union invaded the country in December 1979, placing its lackey Babrak Karmal in putative power in Kabul. The country lurched from disaster to calamity. As Karmal gave way to Najibullah, the Reagan administration in distant Washington, in league with Pakistan's dictator Ziaul Haq, went busily into weaving a new format of agony for Afghanistan. The country haemorrhaged and so did Leonid Brezhnev's soldiers. The Mujahideen, fighting in the name of God, were the elements the Reagan-Zia confederacy armed to the teeth. Chaos was the outcome.

The Soviets achieved nothing, leaving quietly on Mikhail Gorbachev's watch in 1989. Najibullah fell. From pointless communism Afghanistan passed into meaningless religio-political government, with men like Burhanuddin Rabbani taking charge of Kabul. But the Mujahideen, wracked by division and individual ambitions, fell out, shooting at each other. Gulbuddin Hekmatyar and Ahmed Shah Massoud and others drilled holes, literal bullet holes, into the structure of the country. With the communists gone and the Soviets retreating, Washington sat smugly back, its work done.

But it was not done. Debris littered the place and Pakistan would pay the price. In the hundreds and then in the thousands, Afghan refugees would make their way into Pakistan. It was a caravan that would stretch increasingly longer over the coming years. In the post-Zia years, Islamabad's notorious Inter Services Intelligence (ISI) would foster a new team, called Taliban, in place. In 1996, the Taliban, medieval in its outlook, its politics glued to the idea of men wearing beards of particular specifications and women condemned to imprisonment in the home, became the new warlords to seize Afghanistan.

Benazir Bhutto, in power in Islamabad, cheered the rise of the Taliban. The Taliban soon embarked on a journey into the past. They murdered Najibullah and his brother in all the brutality they could muster. They hacked away at and then blew up the Buddha statues in Bamiyan. They offered and gave accommodation to the equally murderous al-Qaeda and Osama bin Laden. September 11 happened, giving George W Bush, questionably placed in the White House by an interfering US Supreme Court, the perfect opportunity to destroy Afghanistan a whole lot more. The raids on the Tora Bora mountains, the infusion of American soldiers, all of this put the Taliban out to pasture. The wings of al-Qaeda were clipped.

Bush and Dick Cheney and Donald Rumsfeld, armed with high notions of their ability to reshape the world, thought they could do nation-building in Afghanistan. In came Hamid Karzai, in his exotically queer attire, imposed on Afghans as their president. His power was confined to the presidential palace, while nervous American and Nato soldiers ensured the country's security. The Karzai administration was a model of inefficiency and corruption. That of his successor Ashraf Ghani was not much of an improvement.

Twenty years after Bush sent American troops into Afghanistan to build democracy through cobbling a nation out of its many tribes, Joe Biden brings those soldiers home, leaving Afghanistan to return to its era of darkness, to its fate. The Taliban are marching back to power, in unstoppable manner. In what is surely an instance of supreme irony, a Taliban team has been to Moscow, perhaps trying to work out its new approach, in its new avatar, to diplomacy. Biden informs the world that the Afghan military is capable of beating back the Taliban onslaught. That is quite a laugh, given that a goodly number of Afghan soldiers, terrified of a band of approaching Taliban fighters, simply crossed the border into safety in Tajikistan.

Afghanistan in all history has never been on its knees before foreign powers. But its blood has always flowed. Blood will flow again. There will be little way of stanching it. That is the nightmare — of the ramifications of a second Taliban rise on Iran, Pakistan, Turkey, Central Asia and the Middle East.

Afghanistan is about to break again. The lights will go out one more time. That will cause hearts to break in millions around the world.

Related Stories