Published : 02 May 2015, 07:40 PM
Updated : 19 Oct 2022, 06:44 PM
Professor Shamsul Alam, member of the Planning Commission’s General Economics Division (GED), raised the questions at a CPD-organised seminar on subsidy management in Dhaka on Saturday.
“The way the paper presented the allotment of subsidy in budgets of various fiscal years does not have objectivity and consistency,” he said, commenting on the keynote paper presented by CPD Visiting Fellow Kaniz Siddique.
She said it was important to properly manage subsidies coming from government’s borrowing from local and foreign financial institutions.
According to Professor Alam, subsidies for food, agriculture, power and several other sectors were almost equal in the past few fiscal years but the keynote paper showed it ‘inconsistently’.
The Planning Commission member said the keynote paper showed food subsidy during 2012-13 fiscal year was 2.51 percent and 6.93 percent during 2014-15 fiscal.
“But the rates of subsidy in budgets showed declining trend,” he argued.
“Similarly, analysis of subsidies for power, jute, BPC and PDB too lack consistency,” the professor said.
Alam said CPD would lose ‘credibility’ if its analysis had such ‘lack of objectivity’.
Centre for Policy Dialogue’s Debapriya Bhattacharya, who moderated the discussion, suggested defining subsidy, marking increase in efficiency and ensuring transparency.
Kaniz Siddique also made some proposals to reform subsidy management.
She said subsidies should be given temporarily for a specific period following a special policy.
“Growth, poverty, and social and environmental development can be considered,” she suggested.
The CPD’s visiting fellow emphasised adopting short-term, mid-term and long-term policies for subsidy expenditure.
“We can take example from successes of other countries in subsidy management,” she said.
She suggested raising salary of private and public officials to decrease subsidy for fuel and power. It means the officials would pay more for fuel and power if their salary were hiked.
She also proposed to stop consumer-level subsidy.
“The farmers will get more benefit if they get fertiliser early instead of giving subsidy for fertiliser,” she said.
Shamsul Alam highlighted self-sufficiency in food while defending subsidies.
“Subsidy is needed to build a welfare state,” he said. “But subsidies need a policy.”
MA Mannan, the state minister for both finance and planning who attended as chief guest, said the main objective of subsidy was to decrease inequality.
“The people wanted to get power at any cost when the government set up rental power plants in 2010. Now the government is setting up coal and gas-run power plants to reduce subsidy,” he said.
The 2007-8 interim finance minister, AB Mirza Azizul Islam said, “There should be a research to find out whether the objective of the subsidy is achieved.”
“Reform, objectivity and transparency are needed while allocating subsidies,” he said.