States turn to tax cuts as inflation stays hot in US

In Kansas, the Democratic governor has been pushing to slash the state’s grocery sales tax. Last month, New Mexico lawmakers provided $1,000 tax rebates to households hobbled by high gas prices. Legislatures in Iowa, Indiana and Idaho have cut state income taxes this year.

A combination of flush state budget coffers and rapid inflation has lawmakers across the country looking for ways to ease the pain of rising prices, with nearly three dozen states enacting or considering some form of tax relief, according to the Tax Foundation, a right-leaning think tank.

The efforts are blurring typical party lines when it comes to tax policy. In many cases, Democrats are joining Republicans in supporting permanently lower taxes or temporary cuts, including for high earners.

But while the policies are aimed at helping Americans weather the fastest pace of inflation in 40 years, economists warn that, paradoxically, cutting taxes could exacerbate the very problem lawmakers are trying to address. By putting more money in people’s pockets, policymakers risk further stimulating already rampant consumer demand, pushing prices higher nationally.

Jason Furman, an economist at Harvard University who was an economic adviser under the Obama administration, said that the United States economy was producing at full capacity right now and that any additional spending power would drive up demand and prices. But when it comes to cutting taxes, he acknowledged, the incentives for states do not always appear to be aligned with what is best for the national economy.

“I think all these tax cuts in states are adding to inflation,” Furman said. “The problem is, from any governor’s perspective, a lot of the inflation it is adding is nationwide and a lot of the benefits of the tax cuts are to the states.”

States are awash in cash after a faster-than-expected economic rebound in 2021 and a $350 billion infusion of stimulus funds that Congress allocated to states and cities last year. While the Biden administration has restricted states from using relief money to directly subsidise tax cuts, many governments have found budgetary workarounds without violating the rules.

Last week, Gov Ron DeSantis of Florida signed a $1.2 billion tax cut that was made possible by budget surpluses. The state’s coffers were bolstered by $8.8 billion in federal pandemic relief money. DeSantis, a Republican, hailed the tax cuts as the largest in the state’s history.

“Florida’s economy has consistently outpaced the nation, but we are still fighting against inflationary policies imposed on us by the Biden administration,” he said.

Adding to the urgency is the political calendar: Many governors and state legislators face elections in November, and voters have made clear they are concerned about rising prices for gas, food and rent.

“It’s very difficult for policymakers to see the inflationary pressures that taxpayers are burdened by right now while sitting on significant cash reserves without some desire to return that,” said Jared Walczak, vice president for state projects with the Center for State Tax Policy at the Tax Foundation. “The challenge for policymakers is that simply cutting checks to taxpayers can feed the inflationary environment rather than offsetting it.”

The tax cuts are coming in a variety of forms and sizes. According to the Tax Foundation, which has been tracking proposals this year, some would be phased in, some would be permanent and others would be temporary “holidays.”

Next month, New York will suspend some of its state gas taxes through the end of the year, a move that Gov Kathy Hochul, a Democrat, said would save families and businesses an estimated $585 million.

In Pennsylvania, Gov Tom Wolf, a Democrat, has called for gradually lowering the state’s corporate tax rate to 5% from 10% — taking a decidedly different stance from many of his political peers in Congress, who have called for raising corporate taxes. Wolf said in April that the proposal was intended to make Pennsylvania more business friendly.

Furman pointed to the budget surpluses as evidence that the $1.9 trillion pandemic relief package handed too much money to local governments.

A new report from the Tax Policy Center, a left-leaning think tank, said total state revenue rose by about 17.6% last year. State rainy day funds — money that is set aside to cover unexpected costs — have reached “new record levels,” according to the National Association of State Budget Officers.

Yet those rosy budget balances may not last if the economy slows, as expected. The Federal Reserve has begun raising interest rates in an attempt to cool economic growth, and there are growing concerns about the potential for another recession. Stocks fell for another session on Monday, with the S&P 500 down 3.2%, as investors fretted about a slowdown in global growth, high inflation and other economic woes.

Cutting taxes too deeply now could put states on weaker financial footing.

The Tax Policy Center said its state tax revenue forecasts for the rest of this year and next year were “alarmingly weak” as states enacted tax cuts and spending plans. Fitch, the credit rating agency, said recently that immediate and permanent tax cuts could be risky in light of evolving economic conditions.

“Substantial tax policy changes can negatively affect revenues and lead to long-term structural budget challenges, especially when enacted all at once in an uncertain economic environment,” Fitch said.

The state tax cuts are taking place as the Biden administration struggles to respond to rising prices. So far, the White House has resisted calls for a gas tax holiday, though Jen Psaki, the White House press secretary, said in April that President Joe Biden was open to the idea. The administration has responded by primarily trying to ease supply chain logjams that have created shortages of goods and cracking down on price gouging, but taming inflation falls largely to the Fed.

The White House declined to assess the merits of states’ cutting taxes but pointed to the administration’s measures to expand fuel supplies and proposals for strengthening supply chains and lowering health and child care costs as evidence that Biden was taking inflation seriously.

“President Biden is taking aggressive action to lower costs for American families and address inflation,” said Emilie Simons, a White House spokesperson.

The degree to which state tax relief fuels inflation depends in large part on how quickly the moves go into effect.

Gov Laura Kelly backed a bill last month that would phase out the 6.5% grocery sales tax in Kansas, lowering it next January and bringing it to zero by 2025. Republicans in the state pushed for the gradual reduction despite calls from Democrats to cut the tax to zero by July.

As Russia’s war in Ukraine drives up energy prices, many states have been debating whether to enact gas tax holidays or send out rebates.

This month, Delaware will begin sending out $300 “relief payments” to adult residents. The bill signed by DeSantis will also spend $200 million of pandemic relief money to suspend its gas tax during October, ahead of the November elections. And Alaska is considering suspending its motor fuel taxes through mid-2023.

Grover Norquist, president of Americans for Tax Reform, a group that promotes lower taxes, has been encouraging governors to eliminate their income taxes altogether and said inflation was changing the calculus of how state officials thought about tax policy. He noted that few Democrats were talking about raising taxes.

“It’s more painful to live in a high-tax state,” Norquist said, suggesting that more mobility because of remote work has forced states to keep their taxes more competitive. “It’s easier to move, and the places you can move to are much more cosmopolitan than they used to be.”

States with high taxes such as New York have been grappling with concerns about residents fleeing for tax purposes. Hochul said this year that she would not support any tax increases, noting that she did not want those who support art, culture and philanthropy in New York City moving to Miami.

The broad effects of tax policy on inflation are not easy to forecast. David Herzig, a partner at Ernst & Young, said that, in theory, taking money out of the economy with higher taxes would depress rising prices, but that if that led workers to demand higher wages, it could have the unintended effect of driving prices even higher.

“We don’t know all the knock-on consequences of these decisions,” Herzig, a former tax law professor, said.

Yet with polling showing that inflation is a top worry among voters this year, policies that address higher prices could be critical to political races. Candidates are increasingly focused on how to help people deal with bigger bills.

In Pennsylvania, Attorney General Josh Shapiro, a Democrat who is running for governor, has proposed eliminating the state’s 11% cellphone tax, expanding a property tax and rent and rebate programme, and providing a $250-per-vehicle gas tax refund. He favoured the gas tax refund, which would be paid for with unused pandemic relief money, over a tax holiday because it ensured that oil companies would not reap the benefits.

Republicans have yet to settle on a candidate for governor and will decide during a primary election this month, but some of those running have called for cutting gas taxes.

On the campaign trail, Shapiro said, voters view higher prices as a major concern and are looking to politicians for answers.

“They talk about the stuff they buy at the grocery store and gas and all of that,” Shapiro said. “It just costs more, and they want someone to do something about it.”

© 2022 The New York Times Company