In India’s city of temples, Narendra Modi is both hero and villain

It was 4 am at the Yadav family home down a narrow lane in Varanasi, the constituency of the Indian prime minister, Narendra Modi. Vijay Yadav, 30, cut buns and toasted them one by one on a gas stove with the help of his mother, Kamla Devi.

>> Mujib Mashal, The New York Times
Published : 24 May 2019, 08:19 AM
Updated : 24 May 2019, 08:19 AM

Yadav is a staunch supporter of Modi, and the snacks were for about 100 party observers at counting stations on Thursday for what would turn out to be a landslide victory for Modi and his Bharatiya Janata Party — both strong proponents of Hindu nationalism in a country that is roughly 15% Muslim.

The Yadav family’s roadside tea stall — which his father, a recent Modi convert, has been running for decades — is decorated with several fading pictures of Modi, including a couple on the refrigerator beneath icons of several Hindu deities. The store sign also bears the prime minister’s nickname: NaMo Tea Stall.

“It took me five years to change my father to support the party and Modi, but my mother always supported,” Vijay Yadav said, as he wiped away sweat with one hand and toasted a bun with the other. “Our whole family campaigned for Modi. We closed the tea stall for 15 days.”

Five years ago, when Modi made formal his longtime ambition of leading India, he chose as his stage and constituency Varanasi, a city of temples and gods. On Thursday, Modi was re-elected to that seat, with a victory margin of nearly half a million votes. His party’s resounding nationwide victory means the powerful and divisive prime minister will lead India for another five years.

Modi is a self-made man, rising from modest beginnings through his party’s Hindu nationalist wing to become the longest-serving chief minister of Gujarat, one of India’s largest states. There, he was known for a blend of business-friendly policies that sped development and the promotion of Hindu nationalist ideology.

Varanasi, an ancient city on the banks of the sacred Ganges River, offered the perfect backdrop to take that mix to the national level. Millions of visitors arrive every year — for pilgrimages, tourism or Moksha, a Hindu belief that the souls of those who are cremated on a funeral pyre by the sacred river will be free from the cycle of reincarnation. To bathe in the river is to wash away one’s sins.

Modi framed his decision to run from Varanasi as a religious calling, intertwining his name with the holy place. If he made progress in modernizing the city, the word-of-mouth from visitors would become a 24/7 image campaign.

“I feel neither that anybody sent me nor that have I come on my own. It is Maa Ganga who has called me,” Modi said, referring to the river as Mother Ganges.

Modi’s mix of chauvinism and development has brought him a solid bloc of Hindu votes at the national level that makes him seem infallible, even when his party is clearly struggling. The party has flaws, many say. But Modi?

“He doesn’t even give love to his own family, because then what is the difference between him and the rest of the politicians,” Vijay Yadav said. “It should be like this, leaving everything behind for the country.”

It is clear that Modi has made his mark on Varanasi, a hugely challenging place for development work because of the traffic that chokes its narrow streets practically around the clock. Several projects — like those to build roads and improve the delivery of electricity and cooking gas — were completed at a swift pace.

“People go on for 24 hours. Working here is impossible,” said Ram Gopal Mohale, a former mayor. “Every month there is a festival here, hundreds of thousands of people. We only get to work for four hours a day. There are prayers from 3am to 11pm, and the cremation pyres go on for 24 hours.”

Modi’s cult of personality has grown so much his followers in the state of Gujarat have built a temple in his name, complete with a statue of the prime minister. A retired engineer in Uttar Pradesh, India’s most populous state, which includes Varanasi, has said he is raising money for a second Modi temple.

Yadav said he had heard of both temples, and his devotion to Modi seemed no less. In addition to the poster at the tea stall, he keeps large photographs of Modi at his home.

“When I see them, it gives me inspiration,” he said.

But Modi’s blend of development and Hindu nationalism — clearly aimed at a larger national audience — has often been unsettling in Varanasi, and has sometimes resulted in dangerous escalations in tensions.

In some neighborhoods, he has buried dangerous overhead electric wires, replacing them with underground cables, but exposed deep communal tensions. He has started a cruise on the Ganges River so tourists can take air-conditioned rides, but struck worry in the hearts of the boatmen who protested that their way of life of hundreds of years was at risk.

Perhaps, the most divisive project has been the construction of a corridor from the famous Kashi Vishwanath temple down to the Ganges. Hundreds of families had to be moved from the area and their homes razed, alienating Hindus and Muslims alike.

“People are coming from all over the world here for salvation, but we are being forced to leave,” said Daya Shankar Srivastava, who runs a clothing shop in one of the few buildings that remain in the area.

Hindu leaders complain that many smaller temples were destroyed to make Modi’s dream project happen. Muslim leaders have another worry: The Vishwanath temple shares a wall with a local mosque that feels increasingly vulnerable to the temple’s expansion.

Swami Avimukteshwaranand, the head of the Sri Vidya Math, a Hindu school in Varanasi, compared the alleged destruction of the temples to build the Vishwanath corridor to the smashing of Hindu icons by Muslim emperors. When challenged on why Modi, a Hindu, would destroy temples, the swami lost his temper.

“Stop,” he screamed, in front of an audience of his followers and a smartphone that appeared to be broadcasting him live. “Does a Hindu destroy temples? Does a Hindu destroy icons? He is not Hindu. He cannot be Hindu.”

SM Yasin, the general secretary of the local mosque association, said the encroachment on the mosque grounds and other instigations over the past five years nearly erupted into bloody clashes on several occasions. A security force of about 1,000 troops helps keep the peace, he said.

Yasin said that Hindus and Muslims had long lived peacefully in Varanasi, but that Modi’s government had broken that trust. “Today, no one is ready to listen,” Yasin said. “If he comes back to power, he is coming with confidence.”

For Yadav, the young devotee, it is Modi’s dedication, and how easily he connects with people, that appeals to him. He also likes Modi’s open embrace of Hindutva, or Hindu nationalism.

“Before Modi, it felt like Hindutva was dead around here,” he said.

The day he met Modi for the first time, during his registration as candidate in 2014, is among his happiest memories. His eyes beam when he recalls how Modi put his hand on his shoulder.

“He told me, ‘A dedicated party worker like you should be in every city, in every town, on every street,’” Yadav said.

As thousands gathered on the steps facing the sacred river for the evening prayer ceremony on Thursday, a large sign with Modi’s “watchman” slogan, projecting himself as the protector of India, floated in front of them in lit letters. The air-conditioned cruise launched during his government was docked next to it. Small boats tried to make their way in between.

And then, as if choreographed perfectly to Modi’s wishes, the sound of the prayers and the jingles mixed with the fireworks of his victory that lit the sky above the Ganges.