Antipathy may have clouded the 16th amendment verdict, says Law Commission chief
Staff Correspondent, bdnews24.com
Published: 19 Aug 2017 03:24 PM BdST Updated: 20 Aug 2017 12:41 AM BdST
The top court's verdict and observations scrapping the 16th amendment may be an outcome of its antipathy towards the government and parliament, says the Law Commission chief.
If that was the case then Chief Justice Surendra Kumar Sinha has lost the eligibility to hold the office, says Justice ABM Khairul Haque.
Haque, who served as the chief justice from 2010 to 2011, made the remarks on Saturday while addressing a discussion in Dhaka.
In an interview with bdnews24.com and two other news outlets on Thursday, he described the verdict as 'flawed' and the observation 'even more flawed'.
The 16th Amendment to the Constitution had restored parliament’s powers to impeach higher court justices.
Last year, the High Court declared the amendment ‘illegal’ and the decision was upheld on Jul 3 by the Appellate Division. The full verdict was finally released by the Supreme Court on Aug 1.
Chief Justice Sinha's observation on Bangladesh's politics, past dictatorships, election commission, corruption, governance and judiciary in the verdict has sparked sharp reactions.
On Saturday, Law Commission Chairman Haque told the discussion, "If a verdict reflects antipathy, then what is the consequence of that judgment? Think about it."
The top judge made observations that 'parliament is immature', 'democracy is immature' and 'parliament did not pay heed to our directives'. "If these observations are made out of antipathy, then where the judge stands?" he asked.
"I ask you to consider whether he is acting beyond the bounds of oath. I am just pointing it out. What will happen if he violates the oath? You know what may happen."
The top court's dismissal of the 16th constitutional amendment, which empowered parliament to remove judges for incapacity or misconduct, stirred reactions from various quarters.
On Thursday, Justice Haque had called the verdict and its observations flawed. He had previously accused Chief Justice SK Sinha of having a ‘pre-conceived notion’ of the 16th amendment.
The BNP, however, hailed the verdict as historic, and criticised Haque's reaction.
“Dual governance is the best system,” said Haque. “After all, judges are not angels. They can also abuse power.”
-
Govt reports 515 new virus cases, 14 deaths
-
481,029 unfit vehicles in Bangladesh
-
First navy chief Nurul Huq dies
-
Kushtia situation must be terrible: HC
-
Two Bangladeshies win Padma Shri award
-
PK Halder, 32 others face embezzlement charges
-
Book fair to open in March: official
-
Kushtia SP apologises for ‘misbehaving’ with magistrate
-
Govt authorises education boards to publish HSC results
-
Bangladesh reports 515 new virus cases, 14 deaths
-
Over 481,000 unfit vehicles in Bangladesh: Obaidul Quader
-
Captain Nurul Huq, first chief of Bangladesh Navy, dies at 86
-
High Court shows concern over Kushtia’s ‘horrible’ situation
-
Sanjeeda Khatun, Sajjad Ali Zahir win India's Padma Shri award
Most Read
- How to register for coronavirus vaccine in Bangladesh
- Bangladesh plans to launch COVID vaccine registration app on Jan 27
- Captain Nurul Huq, first chief of Bangladesh Navy, dies at 86
- Bangladesh reports 515 new virus cases, 14 deaths
- Bangladesh ready to roll out Oxford COVID vaccines after long wait
- Over 481,000 unfit vehicles in Bangladesh: Obaidul Quader
- WHO issues new clinical advice on treating COVID-19 patients
- Regulator approves COVID vaccine samples as Bangladesh gears up for inoculation
- India to honour Sanjeeda Khatun, Sajjad Ali Zahir with Padma Shri award
- Bangladesh agricultural researchers blame government failure to control syndicates for price spikes