Quader Molla hangs, finally, for war crimes

Jamaat-e-Islami leader Abdul Quader Molla has finally been hanged for his crimes against humanity in 1971, in the first execution of a war criminal in Bangladesh.

Tanim Ahmedand Biswadip Das bdnews24.com
Published : 12 Dec 2013, 04:06 PM
Updated : 12 Dec 2013, 10:22 PM

His hanging three days before nation celebrates the 42nd Victory Day caps a drama-filled legal process.

An eleventh hour twist on Tuesday night in the course of events saw Molla’s looming execution stopped — for two days.

He walked the gallows at 10:01 Thursday night. An ambulance carrying Molla’s body came out of the Dhaka Central Jail gates at 11:14pm.

According to a police officer, Khilgaon police OC Sheikh Sirajul Islam, charged with escorting the ambulance, the body will be taken to Molla’s ancestral home in Faridpur.

In an immediate reaction, Molla’s younger brother Molla Mainuddin Ahmed has said all that the Almighty does is always for the best. “He will be the judge of it.”

Mohammad Ali, conducting prosecutor at the tribunal, said, "In light of the pro-liberation spirit and the values of 1971, I am the happiest person in the world, as well as the conducting prosecutor in this case."

Defence counsel Tajul Islam said, "I have nothing to say about it. The people of the world have spoken on it. I believe Quader Molla was innocent. History will judge this."

Attorney General Mahbubey Alam said, “Rule of law has been established through this execution.”

Dhaka University Vice-Chancellor AAMS Arefin Siddique said the people were waiting for this.

“This execution finally fulfils their expectations. I hope other war criminals will also be executed through expedited trials.”

Additional Attorney General and a coordinator tribunal’s prosecution team, MK Rahman said justice had been established after 42 years. “We have finally been able to absolve ourselves (from guilt).”

His party Jamaat-e-Islami has called the execution a “political murder” and taken a vow to exactrevenge for “every drop” of his blood.

The smiling photograph of the ‘butcher of Mirpur’ flashing a victory sign, following a life sentence by the war crimes tribunal on Feb 5, had sparked off a huge public campaign for his death.

Thousands of youths revolted against the verdict terming it “too light”. Then tens of thousands congregated for weeks at Shahbagh crossway's now iconic Prajanma Chattar in a movement led by Ganajagaran Mancha.

Dubbed as the ‘Bangla Spring’ by Western media as it sparked similar protests across the country and abroad, it called for the maximum penalty of convicted war criminals.

The Jamaat Assistant Secretary General was scheduled to be hanged a minute past Tuesday midnight but a last-minute attempt by his lawyers saw the Supreme Court Chamber Judge stay the execution until 10:30 the next morning.

Molla, who had been readied for his execution on Tuesday, was finally hanged at 10:01pm on Thursday.

Hundreds of Ganajagaran Mancha faithfuls hailed the execution as their victory, not too far away from the Dhaka Central Jail where the death sentence was carried out amid tight security, with journalists thronging the jail gate at the dead of a chilly December night.

Life and Death

The second war crimes tribunal on Feb 5 sentenced Molla to life in prison, finding him guilty of murder and other serious crimes.

The Supreme Court, on Sept 17, revised the sentence to death penalty following an appeal by the Prosecution that considered the International Crimes Tribunal-2 sentence too light.

The Supreme Court's award of death penalty was welcomed by thousands at Dhaka’s Shahbagh as a victory of their movement. With the hanging, they felt their long campaign has finally borne fruit.

It is widely perceived that the Shahbagh demonstrations were part of the pressure that eventually had the government amend the International Crimes Act, under which the war crimes trials are being conducted, providing equal opportunities to defence and prosecution to appeal against a sentence.

The amendment allowed the prosecution to appeal against Molla’s sentence seeking a heavier penalty. Previously, the Prosecution could only appeal against an acquittal.

It also paved way for bringing Jamaat under the scanner for its controversial role during the Liberation War.

Molla was indicted for six war crimes charges on May 28 last year including mass murder, conspiracy and instigation in 1971.

His was the second verdict since the Awami League-led government in 2010 initiated the process of trying those who had opposed Bangladesh's birth.
The Jamaat leader challenged his sentence while the prosecution sought maximum penalty.

On Sept 17, the highest court found the Jamaat Assistant Secretary General guilty of previously unproven murders and rape and ruled that he must die for his war-time role.

Molla was popularly known as the ‘Butcher of Mirpur’ for his role during the 1971 Liberation War.

Twist and Turn

On Dec 5, the Supreme Court published the full verdict of its order sentencing Molla to die and three days later, on Sunday, the war crimes tribunal issued a death warrant.

On Monday, two independent UN human rights experts urged Bangladesh to halt the execution of Molla.

The UN also sought to stop the execution. Its High Commissioner for Human Rights Navi Pillay made a last-minute appeal to Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina to stop the execution.

UN Special Rapporteur Gabriela Knaul said, “Anyone convicted of a crime has the right to have his or her conviction and sentence reviewed by a higher tribunal, as laid down in the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights to which Bangladesh is a party.”

"This provision is violated where a court of final instance imposes a harsher sentence that cannot be reviewed," she said in a statement.

On Tuesday evening, State Minister for Home Shamsul Hoque Tuku told the media that the war criminal would be hanged 'tonight'.

State Minister for Law Qamrul Islam claimed that Molla had refused to seek presidential clemency, which is a death row convict’s last resort and his reported ‘refusal’ meant there were no bars to the execution any more.

The defence counsels had met the war crimes convict on Tuesday noon. Jamaat’s chief defence counsel for all the war crimes cases, also an Assistant Secretary General of the party, Abdur Razzaq told the press that Molla had directed him to file a petition to review the Supreme Court ruling.

His client was apparently still pondering over whether to seek the president’s mercy.

They maintained that there was scope for a review petition of the final verdict but the Prosecution argues the Constitution denies basic rights to war crimes convicts.

Jamaat defence counsels went to see Justice Syed Mahmud Hossain, the Chamber Judge, around the same time that State Minister for Home, Tuku, said the verdict would be carried out a minute past midnight.

There were rumours that Molla would be hanged 'soon'. His son Hasan Jamil in the afternoon told bdnews24.com that the prison authorities had sent a letter asking them to meet Molla in jail by 8pm Tuesday.

Molla's wife Sanoara Jahan along with other family members entered the prison at around 7.45pm, half an hour after Tuku's announcement.

Jamil said, “We have informed close relatives about the letter. We are going to meet him.”

Senior Superintendent of jail Forman Ali said 23 family members of Molla entered the prison to meet him.

High Noon

In a last-ditch attempt, Molla’s defence counsels went to see the chamber judge. The delegation reportedly included Razzaq, senior pro-BNP lawyer Khandaker Mahbub Hossain, who also advises Opposition Leader BNP chief Khaleda Zia, and Tajul Islam, who also happens to represent the Jamaat leaders at the war crimes tribunals.

The defence lawyers secured a stay on the execution barely hours before announced time of execution.

In all this, the Attorney General kept repeating that the order was ex-parte and that he had not been notified although the defence lawyers said the top law officer did not pick up his phone when they tried to reach him.

They filed a review petition with the Supreme Court the following day. The same Appellate bench, headed by the Chief Justice, heard the application that day.

On Thursday morning, the apex court decided that the petition was maintainable and went on to hear its merits straightaway. The bench decided that the petition did not have any merits after all and dismissed the defence application after hearing both sides of the argument on Thursday afternoon.

Later the same day, jail authorities said they were awaiting government order to proceed with the execution.

Molla’s family went to see him for a ‘second’ time on Thursday evening.

Jail gate drama

A part of the old capital gradually took on a deserted look.

Security personnel encouraged people to go home even as their numbers went up in the area around the Dhaka Central Jail.

Security measures were beefed up soon around the jail gate after Quader Molla’s family came out having met him, reported bdnews24.com correspondent from the scene.

There has been no official announcement like that on Tuesday when two junior ministers told the media that all preparations were complete and Molla would be hanged a minute after midnight.

Earlier on Thursday, the apex court dismissed Molla’s review petitions apparently removing all hurdles for his execution.

Molla’s defence counsels had secured a stay on his execution in a last ditch attempt on Tuesday evening barely hours before the appointed hour of hanging.

Although there was a meeting among top government officials where Prime Minister's law advisor Shafique Ahmed, also former Law Minister, was present, there has been no official word from anyone.

An appeal from Molla’s lawyers for a meeting was also rejected by the jail authorities after the death row convict’s family came out of the jail at 7:15pm.

Tajul Islam, a defence counsel, told bdnews24.com that a junior lawyer had taken the petition to the prison authorities. “But they rejected it saying it would not be possible to see him.”

There were over 300 RAB and police personnel present around the jail gate at 8:45pm with reinforcements still coming in.

According to the rules, a convict is made to confess his sins and after execution a doctor examines the body before pronouncing the convict dead.

Several high officials were seen entering the Dhaka Central Jail at about 9:10pm.

They included the civil surgeon, Abdul Malek Mridha, DIG Prisons Golam Haider, Additional DIG Iftekhar Ahmed and Maulvi Monir Hossain and RAB-10 Commander, Imran Hossain.

Although there was just one armoured personnel carrier at 8:30pm, four more joined within half an hour around the jail entrance.

The security personnel were busy clearing the streets of bystanders, while over 50 RAB personnel stood alert in flak jackets and protective gears.

[Additional reporting by Liton Haider, Reazul Bashar, Kamal Hossain Talukder and Golam Mujtaba Dhrubo from outside Dhaka Central Jail, and Shamim Ahamed, Suliman Niloy, Quazi Shahreen Haq and Faizul Siddiki]